status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#3889 (This document is informational only and contains no game actions).
=============================== CFJ 3889 =============================== Webmastor is an office. ========================================================================== Caller: Murphy Barred: nix Judge: Jason Judgement: TRUE ========================================================================== History: Called by Murphy: 15 Nov 2020 18:17:25 Assigned to Jason: 15 Nov 2020 20:13:32 Judged TRUE by Jason: 15 Nov 2020 21:53:16 ========================================================================== Caller's Arguments: * Rule 1006 says "An Office is a position described as an Office by the Rules." * Rule 2616 describes the Webmastor's monthly report, but doesn't explicitly say that Webmastor is an office. No other rule mentions Webmastor. * Rule 2143 is titled "Official Reports and Duties", but defines a person's report first and an office's report second, though I don't remember us ever intentionally using the first in isolation. * Webmastor has been defined since June and no one else seems to have questioned this issue till now, though a judgement of TRUE on this basis may be considered an overly broad application of game custom. -------------------------------------------------------------------------- Judge Jason's Arguments: So it appears this is my fault. Proposal 8388, as adopted, enacts a rule that explicitly states that "The Webmastor is an office." However, it appears that the Rulekeepor (*cough* me *cough*) didn't copy the first paragraph when applying the proposal. I'm sorry for making the mistake and any confusion that it has caused. Judged TRUE. Judge Jason's Evidence: ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// ID: 8388 Title: The Webmastor Adoption index: 1.0 Author: nch Co-authors: Enact a rule titled "The Webmastor" with Power=1 and the following text: The Webmastor is an office. The Webmastor's monthly report includes a Directory, a Changelog, a Warning Log, and an Error Log. The Directory lists notable currently maintained public resources. The Changelog lists notable changes to resources. The Warning Log lists notable potential issues, such as inaccurate or aging resources or unintended issues with a public resource. The Error Log lists notable losses of resources - where a resource has become inaccessible, unmaintained, or unusable. Where 'notable' is used in this rule its meaning is up to the Webmastor's discretion. ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////// From https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2020-June/013727.html "Rule 2616", as appearing in the latest SLR: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Rule 2616/0 (Power=1.0) The Webmastor The Webmastor's monthly report includes a Directory, a Changelog, a Warning Log, and an Error Log. The Directory lists notable currently maintained public resources. The Changelog lists notable changes to resources. The Warning Log lists notable potential issues, such as inaccurate or aging resources or unintended issues with a public resource. The Error Log lists notable losses of resources - where a resource has become inaccessible, unmaintained, or unusable. Where 'notable' is used in this rule its meaning is up to the Webmastor's discretion. History: Enacted by P8388 'The Webmastor' (nch), 03 Jun 2020 Annotations: ------------------------------------------------------------------------ From https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2020-November/014393.html ==========================================================================