Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-16 Thread Josef Wolf
On Tue, Jun 13, 2006 at 05:20:13PM +0200, Toralf Lund wrote: And like I also said, in general, allowing partial flush would also address another issue: The one of blocking the entire tape operation when using a holding disk, and getting a dump larger that won't fit on the runtape tapes

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-14 Thread Toralf Lund
I also have one other scenario in mind, though - which is one I've actually come across a number of times: What if a certain DLE due for backup is estimated to be slightly smaller than runtapes*tape size, and thus dumped to holding disk, but then turns out to be slightly larger?

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Toralf Lund
Anyhow, I'd really like to know more about how the spanning actually works. Is it documented anywhere? http://www.amanda.org/docs and FAQ still say that the option does not exist... Try http://wiki.zmanda.org/index.php/Splitting_dumps_across_tapes Yes. Thanks. That's quite

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Paul Bijnens
On 2006-06-13 09:41, Toralf Lund wrote: Anyhow, I'd really like to know more about how the spanning actually works. Is it documented anywhere? http://www.amanda.org/docs and FAQ still say that the option does not exist... Try

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Toralf Lund
2. What happens to the holding disk file after a dump is partially written to tape? Will Amanda keep the entire file, or just what will be written next time around? And what if the holding disk data is split into chunks? Amanda keeps the entire dump, and will be flushed

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Paul Bijnens
On 2006-06-13 10:32, Toralf Lund wrote: 2. What happens to the holding disk file after a dump is partially written to tape? Will Amanda keep the entire file, or just what will be written next time around? And what if the holding disk data is split into chunks? Amanda keeps

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Toralf Lund
Yes indeed. The whole DLE. A singe DLE still needs to be written in one run, possibly using many tapes. Oh no... Like I said, that's a big disappointment. I'm tempted to say that it is not correct to claim that Amanda now suppots tape spanning, if it can't span dumps across tapes written

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Paul Bijnens
On 2006-06-13 12:10, Toralf Lund wrote: Yes indeed. The whole DLE. A singe DLE still needs to be written in one run, possibly using many tapes. Oh no... Like I said, that's a big disappointment. I'm tempted to say that it is not correct to claim that Amanda now suppots tape spanning, if

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Toralf Lund
Paul Bijnens wrote: On 2006-06-13 12:10, Toralf Lund wrote: Yes indeed. The whole DLE. A singe DLE still needs to be written in one run, possibly using many tapes. Oh no... Like I said, that's a big disappointment. I'm tempted to say that it is not correct to claim that Amanda now suppots

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Joshua Baker-LePain
On Tue, 13 Jun 2006 at 12:55pm, Toralf Lund wrote Paul Bijnens wrote: Taping one DLE is several runs opens a can of worms: you have to add a notion of partial succeeded. Restoring then needs some tapes and some holdingdisk files. What if the holdingdisk crashes or accidently rm the files

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Paul Bijnens
On 2006-06-13 12:55, Toralf Lund wrote: Paul Bijnens wrote: On 2006-06-13 12:10, Toralf Lund wrote: Yes indeed. The whole DLE. A singe DLE still needs to be written in one run, possibly using many tapes. Oh no... Like I said, that's a big disappointment. I'm tempted to say that it is not

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Joshua Baker-LePain
On Tue, 13 Jun 2006 at 2:46pm, Toralf Lund wrote Joshua Baker-LePain wrote: To throw my $.02 in here, the situations would be very different. If one is forced to have all DLEs tapeable in one amdump run, then (theoretically), nothing will be left on the holding disk to lose should said

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Joshua Baker-LePain
On Tue, 13 Jun 2006 at 3:05pm, Paul Bijnens wrote On 2006-06-13 12:55, Toralf Lund wrote: It could also help the current minor problem that taping starts only when the DLE is completely dumped to holdingdisk. The current implementation also assumes the tape chunks follow sequentially on the

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Paul Bijnens
On 2006-06-13 15:35, Joshua Baker-LePain wrote: Again, let the curmudgeon step in here. One of the initial design principles of amanda was the ability to get your data off the tapes with *no* amanda tools -- mt, dd, and tar or restore were all that was needed. Tape spanning as implemented

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Jon LaBadie
On Tue, Jun 13, 2006 at 09:35:31AM -0400, Joshua Baker-LePain wrote: On Tue, 13 Jun 2006 at 3:05pm, Paul Bijnens wrote On 2006-06-13 12:55, Toralf Lund wrote: It could also help the current minor problem that taping starts only when the DLE is completely dumped to holdingdisk. The current

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Jon LaBadie
On Tue, Jun 13, 2006 at 02:46:31PM +0200, Toralf Lund wrote: Normally I would agree, but I have to back up 3Tb of data organised as one single volume. The only simple option would be to have one 3Tb tape as well, but such a thing isn't available (to me at least.) Toralf, perhaps I'm being

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Toralf Lund
To throw my $.02 in here, the situations would be very different. If one is forced to have all DLEs tapeable in one amdump run, then (theoretically), nothing will be left on the holding disk to lose should said disk die. But we're talking about a situation where the DLEs are not tapeable.

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Toralf Lund
Jon LaBadie wrote: On Tue, Jun 13, 2006 at 02:46:31PM +0200, Toralf Lund wrote: Normally I would agree, but I have to back up 3Tb of data organised as one single volume. The only simple option would be to have one 3Tb tape as well, but such a thing isn't available (to me at least.)

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Toralf Lund
Toralf Lund wrote: Jon LaBadie wrote: On Tue, Jun 13, 2006 at 02:46:31PM +0200, Toralf Lund wrote: Normally I would agree, but I have to back up 3Tb of data organised as one single volume. The only simple option would be to have one 3Tb tape as well, but such a thing isn't available (to me

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Joshua Baker-LePain
On Tue, 13 Jun 2006 at 4:04pm, Paul Bijnens wrote http://wiki.zmanda.com/index.php/Restoring_files#Using_amrestore_with_split_dumps In that explanation I used amrestore to fetch the chunks from disk to tape, but doing it with a shell script is still doable: - read the first 32K block of the

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-13 Thread Jon LaBadie
On Tue, Jun 13, 2006 at 05:10:53PM +0200, Toralf Lund wrote: I also have one other scenario in mind, though - which is one I've actually come across a number of times: What if a certain DLE due for backup is estimated to be slightly smaller than runtapes*tape size, and thus dumped to

Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-12 Thread Toralf Lund
I haven't been following the posts to this list too closely, or bothered to upgrade amanda, for some time (since our existing setup *works*...), so I didn't find out until right now that tape spanning is supported in the current release. Anyhow, I'd really like to know more about how the

Re: Is tape spanning documented anywhere?

2006-06-12 Thread Matt Hyclak
On Mon, Jun 12, 2006 at 10:18:46AM +0200, Toralf Lund enlightened us: I haven't been following the posts to this list too closely, or bothered to upgrade amanda, for some time (since our existing setup *works*...), so I didn't find out until right now that tape spanning is supported in the