Re: [Anima] WGLC for draft-ietf-anima-constrained-join-proxy-04, ends October 14th 2021

2021-10-02 Thread Brian E Carpenter
Hi, I've looked at this from the GRASP point of view and it all seems fine. It's perhaps worth noting that GRASP DULL discovery is quite independent of both CoAP and DTLS. As far as I know, DTLS still can't protect multicast, so there is no alternative to DULL. (Something the WG should perhaps co

Re: [Anima] Certification Authority renewal/rollover and intra-device communication

2021-10-02 Thread Brian E Carpenter
I *really* don't understand this stuff, but how long could the rollover take, for a reasonably large IoT network (presumably thousands of devices)? Are we talking about a few seconds when no new sessions could start, or what? That said, I don't see that you have much choice. Regards Brian On

[Anima] Certification Authority renewal/rollover and intra-device communication

2021-10-02 Thread Michael Richardson
In: https://github.com/anima-wg/constrained-voucher/pull/177/files We make a compromise on the CA rollover protocol defined RFC4210. Specifically, during the period when devices are renewing their certificates, we do not support communication between devices with different certificates. For inst