Re: [Anima] Call for agenda items ANIMA @ IETF 112

2021-10-28 Thread Liyizhou
Hi chairs, I would like to ask for a slot. Thanks. Topic/Title: Autonomic IP Address To Access Control Groups Mapping Name of Presenter(s): Yizhou Li Length of time requested: 15 min If applicable: name of draft(s) discussed: draft-yizhou-anima-ip-to-access-control-groups Yizhou

Re: [Anima] Discussion regarding draft-dang-anima-network-service-auto-deployment

2021-10-28 Thread Brian E Carpenter
Hi Yujing, On 28-Oct-21 20:18, zhouyujing (A) wrote: Hi Brian, I am very grateful for the GRASP tutorial that you gave me. It solved a lot of my misunderstandings. According your suggestion, I think a GRASP flood is sufficient. The object data we design in the draft is not very large.

Re: [Anima] unsolicited synchronizaiton in draft-yizhou-anima-ip-to-access-control-groups-01.txt

2021-10-28 Thread Brian E Carpenter
On 29-Oct-21 14:19, Liyizhou wrote: Hi Brian, I gave a second thoughts on using the unsolicited sync. I agree with your TCP/UDP comments. So I think the conveying message of mapping info can be changed to rapid mode of discovery instead. That's efficient and simple. And also removes the requ

Re: [Anima] I-D Action: draft-yizhou-anima-l2-acp-based-ani-00.txt

2021-10-28 Thread Brian E Carpenter
Just one comment here: But quite a number of them feel not so comfortable and hard (or not so willing) to understand to build ACP in ipv6 They do not need to understand IPv6 or do anything except check that the IPv6 stack is enabled in all devices. The ACP will deploy itself without requiri

Re: [Anima] unsolicited synchronizaiton in draft-yizhou-anima-ip-to-access-control-groups-01.txt

2021-10-28 Thread Liyizhou
Hi Brian, I gave a second thoughts on using the unsolicited sync. I agree with your TCP/UDP comments. So I think the conveying message of mapping info can be changed to rapid mode of discovery instead. That's efficient and simple. And also removes the requirement of state maintenance. I am al

Re: [Anima] Call for agenda items ANIMA @ IETF 112

2021-10-28 Thread Fries, Steffen
Hi Toerless, hi Cheng We would like to give an overview on BRSKI-AE and the performed document split and the addressed issues. Title: Status of BRSKI-AE and derived work Presenter: Steffen Fries Length: 10 minutes Drafts: - Support of Asynchronous Enrollment in BRSKI (BRSKI-AE), https://datatr

Re: [Anima] Discussion regarding draft-dang-anima-network-service-auto-deployment

2021-10-28 Thread zhouyujing (A)
Hi Brian, I am very grateful for the GRASP tutorial that you gave me. It solved a lot of my misunderstandings. According your suggestion, I think a GRASP flood is sufficient. The object data we design in the draft is not very large. I think 2kB is enough and it will not be sent