Re: [ansible-project] Concerns about the vault implementation

2014-03-03 Thread James Tanner
On 03/02/2014 08:49 PM, David Anderson wrote: Greetings, I've been looking at the crypto that underlies ansible-vault, and I'm worried. Specifically, it seems to me that the vault as implemented is not safe for credential storage. If you haven't read the implementation, this is essentially w

Re: [ansible-project] Concerns about the vault implementation

2014-03-03 Thread Michael DeHaan
We will be reading over this, thanks. If I may summarize most of your concern it seems to me you are saying there shouldn't be a way to verify integrity, because ultimately you will be able to try passwords via the API regardless as you would have been able to ask is this a valid password before.

[ansible-project] Concerns about the vault implementation

2014-03-03 Thread David Anderson
Greetings, I've been looking at the crypto that underlies ansible-vault, and I'm worried. Specifically, it seems to me that the vault as implemented is not safe for credential storage. If you haven't read the implementation, this is essentially what happens when you encrypt a file with ansible-va