Re: [arin-ppml] LACNIC proposal to create a global internet registry

2018-03-23 Thread Jason Schiller
Bill, In your opinion, does the virtual RIR as described in the proposal meet the criteria for RIR establishment in ICP-2? If no, do you see a way the policy could easily be modified to have a greater likelihood of being able to meet the criteria for RIR establishment in ICP-2? ___Jason On Thu

Re: [arin-ppml] LACNIC proposal to create a global internet registry

2018-03-15 Thread william manning
20 years ago, we had a global registry. At the time, the idea of having locally tuned support (TZ, language, etc.) was considered a higher priority than the coherency of a single GIR. But then at the time, the IANA actually had a much more active role in administering policy for what passed as th

Re: [arin-ppml] LACNIC proposal to create a global internet registry

2018-03-15 Thread Bill Woodcock
>> The LACNIC community is discussing a global policy proposal to create a >> Global Internet Registry (GIR). >> https://politicas.lacnic.net/politicas/detail/id/LAC-2018-1;jsessionid=419E05AAC9F2F52E5D27DDCCF4D6B727?language=en I very much support it. The mess that inter-regional transfers and