RE: Lester's extreme compatibility thesis

2003-01-19 Thread Fred Foldvary
--- Gil Guillory [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ... I think there's something to Hoppe's and von Kuehnelt-Leddihn's arguments that monarchy is superior to democracy with regard to this general problem of what we might euphemistically call the externalities of war. Does World War I and its

RE: Lester's extreme compatibility thesis

2003-01-14 Thread Gil Guillory
Sorry, just catching up to this post... First, if war were so expensive relative to peace why does it exist? Maybe peace is more expensive, in terms of risk for example, than open warfare. The costs of war are born by those who pay for and die in the wars, and these people are not the same

Re: Lester's extreme compatibility thesis

2003-01-11 Thread Ben Powell
John, there has been plenty written in the academic journals over the past decade debating your questions. For theoretical arguements look up Tyler Cowen The Economics of Anarchy in Economics and philosophy and David Friedman's response. Dan Sutter's paper Asymetric Power relations in Anarchy

Re: Lester's extreme compatibility thesis

2003-01-10 Thread john hull
What prevents a particular private law enforcement agency from engaging in mob-style protection? For example, in Friedman's Anarchy and Efficient Law, he states that, The most obvious and least likely is direct violence-a mini-war between my agency, attempting to arrest the burglar, and his