Re: [arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-14 Thread ARRvind
riv...@yahoo.com Subject: [arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram' To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Date: Tuesday, April 13, 2010, 3:45 AM   Right, its different composition and different lyrics. By the way, there is Vande Mataram by Usha Utthup as well (in movie Kabhie Khushi

Re: [arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-13 Thread Roshan
: balajirajagopal balajirajago...@... To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com Sent: Mon, 12 April, 2010 8:34:29 AM Subject: [arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram' *Sigh*...wont this subject ever go away. So sick and tired of reading that Jai Ho is not even

[arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-13 Thread Yogesh
No body can take away anything from AR..why Manna Dey's statement is being entertained here? BTW, the sweetest voices on Earth, Lataji and Ashaji always support AR and showers praises on him for his music and his genius..what else you want?..Isn't this best compliment given to AR.. When AR won

Fw: [arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-13 Thread Santosh
RahmanSir Done Gr8 Work by Sing Vande Mataram Gr8 Music By RahmanSir.I respect Manna Deyji as Gr8 classical singer but Why Manna Deyji Commenting on RahmanSir. this is Wrong, Happening in only in India .. When All Over World Respect RahmanSir as Gr8 Musician than Why our People are

[arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-12 Thread azims
Hi!, guys, i dont know if narrow mindedness or somthing else, but let me tell you, on 15 August and 26 Jan no matter waht religion color or race one is, he will sing atleast one Vande Matram after the National Anthem and song. Ar Rahman Sahab has given a new direction to patroitism, and

Fw: [arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-12 Thread Selvin Kumar
 Y v speak like this v cant compare the works and music of rahman , he is great, as a indian v shd think proud of him v shd encourage him more than making such comments come on yar   --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Sriram S srirams_param@ ...

Re: [arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-12 Thread wiredbeats
not the way to sing Vande Mataram' *Sigh*...wont this subject ever go away. So sick and tired of reading that Jai Ho is not even amongst ARR's best songs! If it were true, so be it.but thats not going to change anything ARR rulez --- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, Sriram S

[arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-12 Thread srinivasdas99
I had a good respect for Manna Dey.and a good collection of his songs too. After reading the immature comments about ARR, I hate Manna Dey. Bye ho to Manna Dey and Jai Ho to Rahman. --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Sriram S srirams_pa...@... wrote:   LUCKNOW: For true lovers of

[arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-12 Thread Rivjot
://www.wiredbeats.com From: balajirajagopal balajirajago...@... To: arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com Sent: Mon, 12 April, 2010 8:34:29 AM Subject: [arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram' *Sigh*...wont this subject ever go away. So sick and tired

[arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-11 Thread Elanchezhian
Thats his opinion.But according to me i get goosebumps every single time our boss tells vande mataramViews and opinions differ --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Sriram S srirams_pa...@... wrote:   LUCKNOW: For true lovers of Indian music, he has been a paragon or purity for

[arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-11 Thread vimaljk
Why do we post articles like this in the forum??it just brigns in unnecessary negativity!we need not be bothered if some 90 year old can't appreciate the amazing music of Rahman!...its his loss!...lets not give him and others like him publicity they don't deserve! --- In

[arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-11 Thread AJ
A narrow vision. You know, I find a lot more narrow mindedness in the older generations, including my parents, who have very restricted definitions of what is good music or art. Nothing really wrong in that; just their views and only my observations. If how AR Rahman sang Vande Mataram is

[arr] Re: 'That's not the way to sing Vande Mataram'

2010-04-11 Thread balajirajagopal
*Sigh*...wont this subject ever go away. So sick and tired of reading that Jai Ho is not even amongst ARR's best songs! If it were true, so be it.but thats not going to change anything ARR rulez --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com, Sriram S srirams_pa...@... wrote:   LUCKNOW: