Re: opinions please - build vs buy

2006-05-11 Thread Barry Lindstrom
In my world, this has always been a question of process. IF you have established processes that cannot be altered, that must accomodate special circumstances NOT readily accomodated by out of the box solutions, then you should build. IF however, your processes are a mess and you need to force eve

Re: opinions please - build vs buy

2006-05-10 Thread Nicoll, Alan
Sent: Wednesday, May 10, 2006 4:22 AM To: arslist@ARSLIST.ORG; Nicoll, Alan Subject: Re: opinions please - build vs buy First of all, Thanks to all of the not so lazy posters for your input! How many users? Good question, not sure how it makes to much difference other then the more users we hav

Re: opinions please - build vs buy

2006-05-10 Thread Susan Palmer
** I always thought it would be nice to have a totally complete list of features, almost field by field.  I'm in the process of figuring out which way to go also and trying to do a gap analysis.  It's easy on the product you know, but gets much harder on the ones you aren't as familiar with.  So I'

Re: opinions please - build vs buy

2006-05-10 Thread Stephen Lumini
** In my experience the most important factor is what Chris Woyton said "how large is the gap between what I need and what I can buy?".   Though I would disagree with his third point: "If what you need exceeds or varies considerably from what the ITSM suite provides...determine if using ITSM as

Re: opinions please - build vs buy

2006-05-10 Thread John.A Simpson-contr
First of all, Thanks to all of the not so lazy posters for your input! How many users? Good question, not sure how it makes to much difference other then the more users we have the harder it is to get them to agree on what to build or to buy! The Answer is a little tough since we are continuing t

Re: opinions please - build vs buy

2006-05-09 Thread Sean Garrison
Its kind of like when Jesse James bought a header for a car engine and the header didn't fit. He spent more time trying to make it fit than it would have took him to build the thing. In frustration he threw it across the room and built his own. That is how I describe the ITSM suite. You can was

Re: opinions please - build vs buy

2006-05-09 Thread Nicoll, Alan
How many users do you have? Nick On Tue, 9 May 2006 13:58:57 -0400, John.A Simpson-contr wrote: >BMC/Remedy HelpDesk & Change vs ??? > >background... > >TRW Automotive has been using ARS since 1997, all custom/homegrown >HelpDesk & change management. We have one production server, one test >ser

Re: opinions please - build vs buy

2006-05-09 Thread Davis, David CTR NAVSURFWARCENDIV Crane, Code 0552
Hello John, Remember the licensing costs involved. From: Action Request System discussion list(ARSList) on behalf of John.A Simpson-contr Sent: Tue 5/9/2006 12:58 PM To: arslist@ARSLIST.ORG Subject: opinions please - build vs buy BMC/Remedy HelpDesk

Re: opinions please - build vs buy

2006-05-09 Thread Chris Woyton
John, There are a *ton* of potential constraints here - functionality, budget, plans for ITIL implementations, etc. Probably too large to provide a precise recommendation. In general, this issue almost always boils down to the question "how large is the gap between what I need and what I can buy

opinions please - build vs buy

2006-05-09 Thread John.A Simpson-contr
BMC/Remedy HelpDesk & Change vs ??? background... TRW Automotive has been using ARS since 1997, all custom/homegrown HelpDesk & change management. We have one production server, one test server and one development server. 41 fixed and 63 floats in production. My boss's boss, has asked us to eval