Re: [Asdf-devel] syntax-control branch

2014-06-08 Thread Faré
On Sun, Jun 8, 2014 at 12:09 PM, Robert P. Goldman wrote: > Faré wrote: >> On Sat, Jun 7, 2014 at 8:03 PM, Robert P. Goldman >> wrote: >>> I'm still groping after a clear statement of exactly what class of bugs >>> it is that we are proposing to fix. The existing design document is >>> still to

Re: [Asdf-devel] syntax-control branch

2014-06-08 Thread Robert P. Goldman
Faré wrote: > On Sat, Jun 7, 2014 at 8:03 PM, Robert P. Goldman wrote: >> I'm still groping after a clear statement of exactly what class of bugs >> it is that we are proposing to fix. The existing design document is >> still too vague, proposing to fix >> >> "uncontrolled, unintentional leaking

Re: [Asdf-devel] syntax-control branch

2014-06-08 Thread Faré
On Sat, Jun 7, 2014 at 8:03 PM, Robert P. Goldman wrote: > I'm still groping after a clear statement of exactly what class of bugs > it is that we are proposing to fix. The existing design document is > still too vague, proposing to fix > > "uncontrolled, unintentional leaking of readtable side e

Re: [Asdf-devel] syntax-control branch

2014-06-07 Thread Robert P. Goldman
Faré wrote: > Being able to support most code that change the readtable is worth it. I think part of the problem here is that you are smarter than most of the rest of us (at least me). I'm still groping after a clear statement of exactly what class of bugs it is that we are proposing to fix. The

Re: [Asdf-devel] syntax-control branch

2014-06-06 Thread Faré
On Fri, Jun 6, 2014 at 5:04 PM, Robert P. Goldman wrote: > My large system is broken, but I have not been able to diagnose the > problem. It is turning up *way* downstream. I get a type error where a > class is not getting the right METACLASS. > Is it possible to look at that system? With an NDA

Re: [Asdf-devel] syntax-control branch

2014-06-06 Thread Robert P. Goldman
Faré wrote: > Dear Robert, > > I saw you had another question in the syntax-control.txt document, > about what breaks if you try to work around a readtable conflict by > somehow forcing load order. I replied in the document. > > You say that you had a system that was broken by my branch — did it

Re: [Asdf-devel] syntax-control branch

2014-06-06 Thread Faré
Dear Robert, I saw you had another question in the syntax-control.txt document, about what breaks if you try to work around a readtable conflict by somehow forcing load order. I replied in the document. You say that you had a system that was broken by my branch — did it indeed have a readtable co

Re: [Asdf-devel] syntax-control branch

2014-06-02 Thread Faré
Dear Robert, On Sun, Jun 1, 2014 at 6:25 PM, Robert P. Goldman wrote: > I haven't fully grokked the code changes in the syntax-control branch > yet. However, I have read over the design notes in TODO, and pulled > them out into a separate file, which I am attaching here. I have > annotated with

[Asdf-devel] syntax-control branch

2014-06-01 Thread Robert P. Goldman
I haven't fully grokked the code changes in the syntax-control branch yet. However, I have read over the design notes in TODO, and pulled them out into a separate file, which I am attaching here. I have annotated with a number of open questions, and added a bullet point to document rationale, whi