Re: [Assam] Adivasi Politics in Assam

2007-12-11 Thread baruah
Dear Mahanta, Thanks. The Op-ed column of a newspaper is precisely to accommodate views that are different from the editorial stance. To be fair, the Telegraph solicited this article. You are right. I could have been clearer there. I think the very idea that a group will could get the status

Re: [Assam] Adivasi Politics in Assam

2007-12-11 Thread Roy, Santanu
] Adivasi Politics in Assam http://www.telegraphindia.com/1071211/asp/opinion/story_8654412.asp The Telegraph, Calcutta. Tuesday, December 11, 2007 READING THE TEA LEAVES - The understanding of tribal status must be rid of colonial errors SANJIB BARUAH After the mayhem

Re: [Assam] Adivasi Politics in Assam

2007-12-11 Thread Chan Mahanta
Thanks Baruah. His group -- the Khasis -- were primitive once, and he has to check if the the adivasis also can pass the test of primitiveness. It is probably because of the implied primitiveness test, the adivasis bring bows and arrows to the street. How absurd can one get? Now I

[Assam] Adivasi Politics in Assam

2007-12-10 Thread Sanjib Baruah
http://www.telegraphindia.com/1071211/asp/opinion/story_8654412.asp The Telegraph, Calcutta. Tuesday, December 11, 2007 READING THE TEA LEAVES - The understanding of tribal status must be rid of colonial errors SANJIB BARUAH After the mayhem in Guwahati around the adivasi rally of November

Re: [Assam] Adivasi Politics in Assam

2007-12-10 Thread umesh sharma
Sanjib-da, I must admit your article reads well . Well written. And as a member of the dominant community speaking for the poor and needy you are eloquent. Now the question arises - do Bodos need ST status in Delhi or UP jobs -- wont it help the Bodos and Nagas if their tribal status was

Re: [Assam] Adivasi Politics in Assam

2007-12-10 Thread Shantikam Hazarika
Umesh: Ranjit Mushahary who hails from the interior of Kokrajhar district served as an IPS officer of the Kerala cadre and rose to command the elite National Security Guards. Mr. HT Sangliana, a Mizo from manipur is a sitting MP of Bangalore. Shantikam On Dec 11, 2007 9:06 AM, umesh sharma [EMAIL

Re: [Assam] Adivasi Politics in Assam

2007-12-10 Thread umesh sharma
Shantikam-da, Adivasis can become IPS officers in Assam even now thru ST quota - from their home states Jharkhand, Orissa, Rajasthan etc There are lots of Meenas (from Meena tribe on ST status) from Rajasthan who are IPS, IAS officers all over India. . Mr Mushahary cannot be recruited by