Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Doug Traylor
- Original Message - From: "Doug Traylor" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Monday, February 12, 2007 7:43 PM Subject: Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header > use it because the project is ~dead and hasn't had any updates in almost a &g

Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Doug Traylor
> Users like me have all inbound mail route through an ISP. This adds one > received line to the top of the header file. > > The problem is, that this line makes it impossible to use the great RTBL > feature. How about adding a pre-processing option to strip the first > "received" line? Until I

Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Kevin
Michelle Dupuis wrote: > 1. A spammer is unlikely to add a blacklisted IP to a forged message (and > if they do, their messages deserves to be killed anyways) True, but what if they spoofed a whitelisted IP address? > 2. If the connecting IP is legit (as it would be coming through our ISP), > t

Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Fritz Borgstedt
>I personally would vote no on such a feature, I've used GFI >mailessentials that does this and frankly it's only caught false >positives using the other headers. This feature is not for you, but for people, who do *no* DNS-queries in ASSP today. So giving them the feature does not add to the l

Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Michelle Dupuis
lient's IP is updated. MD -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Kevin Sent: Monday, February 12, 2007 1:51 PM To: Questions and Answers for users of ASSP Anti-Spam SMTP Proxy Subject: Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received

Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Kevin
Michelle Dupuis wrote: > A lot of companies are using 3rd part services as a backup MX (queuing) for > disaster recovery etc; so mail is routed through that ISP. > > You're right about stripping off the first received line can be handled > differently - perhaps the RTBL processing can match all IP

Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Fritz Borgstedt
>A lot of companies are using 3rd part services as a backup MX >(queuing) for >disaster recovery etc; so mail is routed through that ISP. Yeah, but it is waste. And completely unnessary. - Using Tomcat but need to do more?

Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Michelle Dupuis
eader? MD -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Kevin Sent: Monday, February 12, 2007 12:42 PM To: Questions and Answers for users of ASSP Anti-Spam SMTP Proxy Subject: Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header Michelle D

Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Kevin
Michelle Dupuis wrote: > I would like to throw out a feature request - which sounds (based on my > little knowledge) like and easy fix/implementation. > > Users like me have all inbound mail route through an ISP. This adds one > received line to the top of the header file. > > The problem is, th

Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Fritz Borgstedt
Questions and Answers for users of ASSP Anti-Spam SMTP Proxy schreibt: >Users like me have all inbound mail route through an ISP. This adds >one >received line to the top of the header file. One line? You are sure? ISPs like myself may add some hops between receiving and forwarding ---

Re: [Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Fritz Borgstedt
Questions and Answers for users of ASSP Anti-Spam SMTP Proxy schreibt: >The problem is, that this line makes it impossible to use the great >RTBL >feature. How about adding a pre-processing option to strip the first >"received" line? That would do nothing to enable this features for ASSP. ASSP i

[Assp-user] Feature request: Strip first received line of header

2007-02-12 Thread Michelle Dupuis
I would like to throw out a feature request - which sounds (based on my little knowledge) like and easy fix/implementation. Users like me have all inbound mail route through an ISP. This adds one received line to the top of the header file. The problem is, that this line makes it impossible to u