[asterisk-users] To DB or not to DB?

2007-11-28 Thread Alan Lord
I lurk and comment a little on here and have been playing with * for a short while. I am interested in hearing about the pros and cons for using a database backend to Asterisk. My current setup is simple, out of the box with config files in /etc/asterisk and logs etc going into /var. I notice

Re: [asterisk-users] To DB or not to DB?

2007-11-28 Thread C F
just my $0.02. don't interduce any other point of failure into a phone system. unless the need outweigh the disadvantage. On 11/28/07, Alan Lord <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I lurk and comment a little on here and have been playing with * for a > short while. > > I am interested in hearing about t

Re: [asterisk-users] To DB or not to DB?

2007-11-28 Thread Doug Lytle
Alan Lord wrote: > I notice a great many of the contributors here seem to use a db backend > I use it to add features that that change quite often. Black lists, meetme conferences, caller-id lookups, DID routing, fax2email, etc. I just make sure that nothing that I add, if it were to fail

Re: [asterisk-users] To DB or not to DB?

2007-11-28 Thread Mindaugas Kezys
Sent: Wednesday, November 28, 2007 6:22 PM To: asterisk-users@lists.digium.com Subject: [asterisk-users] To DB or not to DB? I lurk and comment a little on here and have been playing with * for a short while. I am interested in hearing about the pros and cons for using a database backend to Ast

Re: [asterisk-users] To DB or not to DB?

2007-11-28 Thread Robert McNaught
I think the answer to this really depends on how regularly you make changes to your config. Adding a database connection increases the complexity (although it is not rocket science) and adds moving parts and therefore has more things to go wrong. If you are using Dynamic realtime, then you are re

Re: [asterisk-users] To DB or not to DB?

2007-11-28 Thread Matt Darnell
On Nov 28, 2007 8:48 AM, Mindaugas Kezys <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Pros: > > 1. No need to reload Asterisk when you change settings > Is reloading the text based config that dangerous? Is there a memory leak or something? How many times can you reload before you should restart Asterisk? -Th

Re: [asterisk-users] To DB or not to DB?

2007-11-28 Thread Anthony Francis
The disadvantages of using the DB are: 1. Learning curve, or getting a good UI that can be flexible when working with the DB for AMC. 2. Many features such as hinting (BLF) do not work with realtime. Benefits: 1. Centralized storage 2. Rapid change deployment( i.e. update sip set context = 'Lo

Re: [asterisk-users] To DB or not to DB?

2007-11-28 Thread Philipp Kempgen
Anthony Francis wrote: > 2. Many features such as hinting (BLF) do not work with realtime. That's only true if *extensions.conf* comes from a db table. Regards, Philipp Kempgen -- amooma GmbH - Bachstr. 126 - 56566 Neuwied - http://www.amooma.de Let's use IT to solve problems and not to

Re: [asterisk-users] To DB or not to DB?

2007-11-29 Thread Alan Lord
Thanks to all the people who commented. It sounds like I don't really need it currently, but worth experimenting with for larger deployments. Cheers Alan -- The way out is open! http://www.theopensourcerer.com ___ --Bandwidth and Colocation Provide

Re: [asterisk-users] To DB or not to DB?

2007-11-30 Thread Benny Amorsen
> "PK" == Philipp Kempgen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: PK> Anthony Francis wrote: >> 2. Many features such as hinting (BLF) do not work with >> realtime. PK> That's only true if *extensions.conf* comes from a db table. Nope, turn off caching and use realtime for SIP peers, and suddenly BLF do