Re: Latest on the comments extension

2005-07-22 Thread Thomas Broyer
James M Snell wrote: /in-reply-to provides the atom:id (not dereferencable) of an original atom:entry and may appear within atom:feed or atom:entry. in-reply-to on the feed level indicates that all of the entries within the feed are considered replies to the identified atom:entry. Is it

Re: Latest on the comments extension

2005-07-22 Thread James M Snell
Thomas Broyer wrote: James M Snell wrote: /in-reply-to provides the atom:id (not dereferencable) of an original atom:entry and may appear within atom:feed or atom:entry. in-reply-to on the feed level indicates that all of the entries within the feed are considered replies to the identified

Latest on the comments extension

2005-07-21 Thread James M Snell
I've been continuing to tweak the comments extension and believe that I am nearing a stable enough version to draft up the I-D. Here's what I've got currently: http://www.snellspace.com/wp/?p=194 There are three link relations: * http://purl.org/syndication/thread/1.0/comments *

Re: Latest on the comments extension

2005-07-21 Thread A. Pagaltzis
* James M Snell [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2005-07-21 23:15]: Feedback requested. I like it so far; comments follow (no pun intended). /root provides the URL (dereferencable) to the Atom feed that contains the original entries and may appear within atom:feed and/or atom:entry Why is this

Re: Latest on the comments extension

2005-07-21 Thread James M Snell
A. Pagaltzis wrote: * James M Snell [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2005-07-21 23:15]: Feedback requested. I like it so far; comments follow (no pun intended). ;-) /root provides the URL (dereferencable) to the Atom feed that contains the original entries and may appear within atom:feed

Re: Latest on the comments extension

2005-07-21 Thread A. Pagaltzis
* James M Snell [EMAIL PROTECTED] [2005-07-22 01:25]: For instance, if I linked to anything but an Atom feed, what would in-reply-to link to? Still atom:id values. Presumably, any resource linked to is associated, by whatever means, to the Atom feed containing the entry being replied to. I don’t