Re: atom:updated vs entry inheritance?

2005-05-13 Thread Henry Story
On 12 May 2005, at 23:22, Eric Scheid wrote: On 13/5/05 7:12 AM, Henry Story [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Just to recapitulate: we have 2 feed documents with successive atom updated values, and with the same entry (same id) with the same time stamp but some values that are not identical. Does

atom:updated vs entry inheritance?

2005-05-12 Thread Eric Scheid
Gah! What is the true atom:updated for the following entry? feed updated2005-05-12T02:22:59+/updated author.../author copyright.../copyright entry updated2005-05-11T01:11:59+/updated id.../id summary.../summary title.../title /entry

Re: atom:updated vs entry inheritance?

2005-05-12 Thread Roger B.
Gah! What is the true atom:updated for the following entry? Eric: The entry-level version, IMO. -- Roger Benningfield

Re: atom:updated vs entry inheritance?

2005-05-12 Thread Antone Roundy
On Thursday, May 12, 2005, at 12:20 PM, Thomas Broyer wrote: Eric Scheid wrote: Gah! What is the true atom:updated for the following entry? feed updated2005-05-12T02:22:59+/updated author.../author copyright.../copyright entry updated2005-05-11T01:11:59+/updated

Re: atom:updated vs entry inheritance?

2005-05-12 Thread Eric Scheid
On 13/5/05 4:39 AM, Antone Roundy [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Eric, was your point that the entry might be inheriting data from the feed which was updated after the entry was updated, and therefore, the entry might be thought of as having been updated after it's atom:updated timestamp? Other

Re: atom:updated vs entry inheritance?

2005-05-12 Thread Henry Story
On 12 May 2005, at 18:49, Eric Scheid wrote: On 13/5/05 2:04 AM, Roger B. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Gah! What is the true atom:updated for the following entry? Eric: The entry-level version, IMO. What if an atom processor had previously seen that entry with that atom:updated ... should it do

Re: atom:updated vs entry inheritance?

2005-05-12 Thread Eric Scheid
On 13/5/05 7:12 AM, Henry Story [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Just to recapitulate: we have 2 feed documents with successive atom updated values, and with the same entry (same id) with the same time stamp but some values that are not identical. Does the newer feed document trump the older one?

Re: atom:updated vs entry inheritance?

2005-05-12 Thread Bill de hÓra
Eric Scheid wrote: I agree. You can see how easy it would be to not do that though. It could also be argued that the publisher has signalled the significance by updating /feed/updated, and thus effectively /feed/entry/. The ambiguity bothers me. thus effectively, does not follow. That's not