Re: [aur-general] Should "base" packages be listed as dependencies?

2017-03-29 Thread Baptiste Jonglez
So, I didn't think such a technical question would spark so much passion! Maybe this discussion should indeed go to arch-dev-public. In the meantime, I see 4 positions emerge from the discussion: 1) packages in "base" *should* be explicitely listed as dependencies (either for mere "technical c

Re: [aur-general] Should "base" packages be listed as dependencies?

2017-03-29 Thread Bruno Pagani via aur-general
Le 29 mars 2017 00:32:09 GMT-07:00, Baptiste Jonglez a écrit : >So, I didn't think such a technical question would spark so much >passion! >Maybe this discussion should indeed go to arch-dev-public. Probably, since this is not just discussing the AUR policy but packaging at the whole scale.

Re: [aur-general] Should "base" packages be listed as dependencies?

2017-03-29 Thread LoneVVolf
On 29-03-17 09:32, Baptiste Jonglez wrote: So, I didn't think such a technical question would spark so much passion! Maybe this discussion should indeed go to arch-dev-public. In the meantime, I see 4 positions emerge from the discussion: 1) packages in "base" *should* be explicitely listed as

Re: [aur-general] Should "base" packages be listed as dependencies?

2017-03-29 Thread Giancarlo Razzolini
Em março 29, 2017 4:32 Baptiste Jonglez escreveu: So, I didn't think such a technical question would spark so much passion! Maybe this discussion should indeed go to arch-dev-public. In the meantime, I see 4 positions emerge from the discussion: 1) packages in "base" *should* be explicitely lis

Re: [aur-general] Should "base" packages be listed as dependencies?

2017-03-29 Thread Xyne
On 2017-03-25 16:31 +0100 Tinu Weber wrote: >On Sat, Mar 25, 2017 at 09:19:43 +0100, Ralf Mardorf wrote: >> On Sat, 25 Mar 2017 06:47:07 +, Xyne wrote: >> >A bash script should depend only on bash. >> >> Hi Xyne, >> >> Seems to be better it would depend on coreutilsor do you asume a bash

Re: [aur-general] Review and a bit of other help request

2017-03-29 Thread Uwe Koloska
Hi Konstantin, sorry for not being clear enough for you to understand what I wanted to say. I haven't looked at your PKGBUILD but just tried to give you some hints from where you may be able to find the cause of your trouble. Maybe I should try again ;-) PKGBUILD is just a bash script that is s