Re: [Axiom-developer] Must hear....

2014-05-12 Thread daly
>> Unless there is some overarching reason it is hard to see the need to >> rewrite existing code. A new design that regularizes many domains >> might make a good reason. A complete extension of the whole area, such >> as a major matrix package might make DHMATRIX a useless subset. But >> changing

Re: [Axiom-developer] Must hear...

2014-05-12 Thread Martin Baker
On 11/05/14 21:33, Tim Daly wrote: Unless there is some overarching reason it is hard to see the need to rewrite existing code. A new design that regularizes many domains might make a good reason. A complete extension of the whole area, such as a major matrix package might make DHMATRIX a useless

Re: [Axiom-developer] Must hear...

2014-05-11 Thread Tim Daly
> So what should one do if one wants to modify parts of Axiom (or its > forks) where all there is is the code? > > Should one: > 1) Trace through the code and try to reverse engineer the documentation, > then modify that. > 2) Try to understand generally what it does (such as working out what >

Re: [Axiom-developer] Must hear...

2014-05-11 Thread u1204
> So what should one do if one wants to modify parts of Axiom (or its > forks) where all there is is the code? > > Should one: > 1) Trace through the code and try to reverse engineer the documentation, > then modify that. > 2) Try to understand generally what it does (such as working out what >

Re: [Axiom-developer] Must hear...

2014-05-11 Thread Martin Baker
On 09/05/14 18:16, Tim Daly wrote: With respect to "documentation" of open source software... "You keep using that word. I don't think it means what you think it means." -- "The Princess Bride" The notion that "reading the code" is the ultimate truth for "documentation" is based on a misunderst

[Axiom-developer] Must hear...

2014-05-09 Thread daly
There is a 3rd part to this series. Enjoy... Robert Lefkowitz -- The Semasiology of Open Source (part 3) http://daviding.wordpress.com/2007/10/22/robert-lefkowitz-the-semasiology-of-open-source-part-iii-oscon-2007-it-conversations-20060726/ Tim ___ Ax

[Axiom-developer] Must hear...

2014-05-09 Thread Tim Daly
With respect to "documentation" of open source software... "You keep using that word. I don't think it means what you think it means." -- "The Princess Bride" The notion that "reading the code" is the ultimate truth for "documentation" is based on a misunderstanding at so many levels it is hard t