RE: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Anne Thomas Manes
sage- From: Elliot Metsger [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, August 18, 2004 4:00 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions Anand et. al, Can you offer your perspective on the interoperability of rpc/lit in the future? Dosen't the WS-I Basic Profile 1

RE: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Anne Thomas Manes
sage- From: Elliot Metsger [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, August 18, 2004 4:00 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions Anand et. al, Can you offer your perspective on the interoperability of rpc/lit in the future? Dosen't the WS-I Basic Profile 1

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Elliot Metsger
Anand: Many thanks for the summary! Anand Natrajan wrote: doc/lit of course decouples the request/response from a procedural model on the server side, which is nice and fine philosophically, but practically, doesn't affect me much. I suspect it doesn't affect many others as well, especially those

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Charles Roy
Yes, right now it's rpc/enc. The overloading is a management decision for me - there's really no flexibility despite talking about some of these issues. Definitely important points for others to consider before doing it though. Thanks, Charles Nelson Minar wrote: Is it possible to overload method

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Anand Natrajan
Elliot, In general, reducing functionality will raise interoperability issues - that observation applies to the deprecation of rpc/literal as well. Given the two major style/usage combinations, i.e., rpc/encoded and document/literal, the latter seems to me a superior model mainly because all refe

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Nelson Minar
>Is it possible to overload methods and use the WSDL2Java tool to >generate the stubs for the overloaded methods. It may work, but it's probably a bad idea. WS-I Basic Profile explicitly forbids overloading methods. And I wouldn't count on interop on other platforms. You said elsewhere you were d

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Elliot Metsger
Anand et. al, Can you offer your perspective on the interoperability of rpc/lit in the future? Dosen't the WS-I Basic Profile 1.0 go a ways to reducing opportunities for interoperability issues? Thanks, Elliot (a ws newbie) Anand Natrajan wrote: Charles and Steve, Mostly for my curiousity, are

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Steve Piercey
Yes, you are right. I'm using rpc/encoding. I'll have to keep the doc/lit stuff in mind. For now, rpc does the job for me Steve - Original Message - From: "Anand Natrajan" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Wednesday, August 18, 200

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Anand Natrajan
Charles and Steve, Mostly for my curiousity, are you using an rpc/encoded service or a document/literal service? My information may be wrong, but I believe the latter doesn't support overloaded methods. Given that the web services world is moving to doc/lit, having overloaded methods may be ill-ad

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Charles Roy
Thanks Steve, Got it now on the same setup. Looks like the problem was in the WSDL file. Explicitly setting the name attribute of the operation within the binding and then have it correspond to the name attribute of the input in the corresponding portType operation fixed it. XMLSpy v5 r2 messed

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Steve Piercey
It works for me in Axis 1.1 with Tomcat 5 Steve . - Original Message - From: "Charles Roy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Wednesday, August 18, 2004 1:55 PM Subject: WSDL2Java overloading functions > Hi, > > Is it possible to overload methods and use the WSDL2Java t