RE: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Anne Thomas Manes
sage- From: Elliot Metsger [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, August 18, 2004 4:00 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions Anand et. al, Can you offer your perspective on the interoperability of rpc/lit in the future? Dosen't the WS-I Basic Profile 1

RE: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Anne Thomas Manes
sage- From: Elliot Metsger [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, August 18, 2004 4:00 PM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions Anand et. al, Can you offer your perspective on the interoperability of rpc/lit in the future? Dosen't the WS-I Basic Profile 1

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Elliot Metsger
Anand: Many thanks for the summary! Anand Natrajan wrote: doc/lit of course decouples the request/response from a procedural model on the server side, which is nice and fine philosophically, but practically, doesn't affect me much. I suspect it doesn't affect many others as well, especially those

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Charles Roy
Yes, right now it's rpc/enc. The overloading is a management decision for me - there's really no flexibility despite talking about some of these issues. Definitely important points for others to consider before doing it though. Thanks, Charles Nelson Minar wrote: Is it possible to overload method

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Anand Natrajan
Elliot, In general, reducing functionality will raise interoperability issues - that observation applies to the deprecation of rpc/literal as well. Given the two major style/usage combinations, i.e., rpc/encoded and document/literal, the latter seems to me a superior model mainly because all refe

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Nelson Minar
>Is it possible to overload methods and use the WSDL2Java tool to >generate the stubs for the overloaded methods. It may work, but it's probably a bad idea. WS-I Basic Profile explicitly forbids overloading methods. And I wouldn't count on interop on other platforms. You said elsewhere you were d

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Elliot Metsger
Anand et. al, Can you offer your perspective on the interoperability of rpc/lit in the future? Dosen't the WS-I Basic Profile 1.0 go a ways to reducing opportunities for interoperability issues? Thanks, Elliot (a ws newbie) Anand Natrajan wrote: Charles and Steve, Mostly for my curiousity, are

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Steve Piercey
> : > > : >Steve > : >. > : > > : >- Original Message - > : >From: "Charles Roy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > : >To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > : >Sent: Wednesday, August 18, 2004 1:55 PM > : >Subject: WSDL2Java overloading functions > : > > : > > : > > : > > : >>Hi, > : >> > : >>Is it possible to overload methods and use the WSDL2Java tool to > : >>generate the stubs for the overloaded methods. > : >> > : >>Thanks, > : >>Charles > : >> > : >> > : >> > : >> > : >> > : > : > : >

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Anand Natrajan
hanks, : Charles : : Steve Piercey wrote: : : >It works for me in Axis 1.1 with Tomcat 5 : > : >Steve : >. : > : >- Original Message - : >From: "Charles Roy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> : >To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> : >Sent: Wednesday, August 18, 20

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Charles Roy
- From: "Charles Roy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Wednesday, August 18, 2004 1:55 PM Subject: WSDL2Java overloading functions Hi, Is it possible to overload methods and use the WSDL2Java tool to generate the stubs for the overloaded methods. Thanks, Charles

Re: WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Steve Piercey
It works for me in Axis 1.1 with Tomcat 5 Steve . - Original Message - From: "Charles Roy" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Wednesday, August 18, 2004 1:55 PM Subject: WSDL2Java overloading functions > Hi, > > Is it possible to overloa

WSDL2Java overloading functions

2004-08-18 Thread Charles Roy
Hi, Is it possible to overload methods and use the WSDL2Java tool to generate the stubs for the overloaded methods. Thanks, Charles