Re: [bess] An use-case that RFC 8584 (EVPN DF Framework)  works not so well and its solution .

2019-04-30 Thread Rabadan, Jorge (Nokia - US/Mountain View)
Hi Bob, Here is my two cents: * The FSM in RFC8584 is not new and has many implementations by now. I would recommend to stay with it. * The timer is generic and gives some room to collect ES routes. You may already have the routes in the PE in your case, but if the node boots and

[bess] An use-case that RFC 8584 (EVPN DF Framework)  works not so well and its solution .

2019-04-29 Thread wang.yubao2
Hi everyone, I reviewed the draft-09 of RFC 8584 a few days ago, and found that the DF Election FSM can't work well after the ES goes UP for the second time. I described it in detail in this mail: https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/bess/9fK2HHdish3b5Hosa5ZU4NKwX7o And I think the

[bess] An use-case that RFC 8584 (EVPN DF Framework)  works not so well and its solution .

2019-04-29 Thread wang.yubao2
Hi everyone, I reviewed the draft-09 of RFC 8584 a few days ago, and found that the DF Election FSM can't work well after the ES goes UP for the second time. I described it in detail in this mail: https://mailarchive.ietf.org/arch/msg/bess/9fK2HHdish3b5Hosa5ZU4NKwX7o And I think the