Hi Antoine,
Thanks for your very interesting suggestions!
On Mon, 23 Jan 2023 at 20:53, darosior wrote:
> Actually you can save a few more characters, and gain some clarity, by
> showing the "semantic policy" instead of the actual Miniscript. If the intent
> is for the user to verify the sema
Hello Salvatore,
It's not something about the specifications of wallet policies, but regarding
the guidelines for implementers on signing devices. Quoting BIP-wallet-policies:
> Moreover, other limitations like the limited size of the screen might affect
> what design choices are available in p
Hi list,
Following up on this topic, I now opened a pull request with the BIP
proposal:
https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/pull/1389
I also attempted a proof-of-concept of how an integration of wallet
policies to HWI might look like:
https://github.com/bitcoin-core/HWI/pull/647
which mi
I'm really happy to see this discussion. I don't have any comments on the spec
because I think I'd have to be more in-the-weeds trying to implement a hww to
understand how well it works for realistic use cases. But a strong concept-ACk
from me and thanks to Salvatore for exploring this!
On Mon, M
Hi all,
TL;DR: It is easy to convert from wallet policy to descriptors and back;
imho aliases are better left out of descriptors in real world usage; some
more examples given.
I received some very useful feedback on the wallet policy proposal (in this
list and outside); that also led me to realiz
Hi Antoine and Billy,
Thank you for your comments and for looking into the proposal.
On Mon, 9 May 2022 at 12:36, darosior wrote:
> 1. The `` optimization for the common usecase of using 2
> descriptors at different derivation indices
>for receive and change. [1]
> 2. The `/**` optimization
Thanks for taking the time to write up about the implementation of output
descriptors on signing devices, and
for proposing a method to overcome encountered difficulties for the following
implementers.
I have some questions with regard to the modifications to the descriptor
language required to
I took a look at the spec for the wallet descriptor format, and I like the
concept of having placeholder variables for keys. It reduces the size of
the descriptor, makes it substantially easier for a human to
read/verify, especially in the future when we have more complex
scripts, and provides a ni
In the implementation work to implement descriptors and miniscript support
in hardware wallets [a][b], I encountered a number of challenges. Some of
them are technical in nature (e.g. due to constraints of embedded
development). Others are related to the attempts of shaping a good user
experience;
