Re: [Bitcoin-development] Proposal: PoW-based throttling of addresses (was: Outbound connections rotation)

2014-11-26 Thread Isidor Zeuner
Hi Mike, thanks for your assessment. Please find my replies in-line: DKIM is hardly a PoW; signing is cheap and gets cheaper all the time. I used to work in the email business and big bulk mailers all spent far more CPU time on other aspects of their business, the overhead of DKIM is

Re: [Bitcoin-development] Proposal: PoW-based throttling of addresses (was: Outbound connections rotation)

2014-11-18 Thread Mike Hearn
DKIM is hardly a PoW; signing is cheap and gets cheaper all the time. I used to work in the email business and big bulk mailers all spent far more CPU time on other aspects of their business, the overhead of DKIM is irrelevant. PoW didn't work in the anti spam world because it (amongst other

Re: [Bitcoin-development] Proposal: PoW-based throttling of addresses (was: Outbound connections rotation)

2014-11-13 Thread Isidor Zeuner
Hi Mike, hi Ivan, hi all, Since when? This has been a recognized approach since people called it hashcash ([1] - before cryptocurrencies were even invented). I only know of one site that worked the way you propose: TicketMaster, a long time ago. They used it as a less harsh form of

Re: [Bitcoin-development] Proposal: PoW-based throttling of addresses (was: Outbound connections rotation)

2014-08-23 Thread Isidor Zeuner
Hi Mike, thanks for your assessment. Please find my replies in-line: Misbehaving addresses can have their connecting difficulty scaled up, which should make it uneconomic to try to DoS the usage of Tor exit nodes for connecting to Bitcoin. You can't solve DoS by requiring all clients

Re: [Bitcoin-development] Proposal: PoW-based throttling of addresses (was: Outbound connections rotation)

2014-08-23 Thread Mike Hearn
Since when? This has been a recognized approach since people called it hashcash ([1] - before cryptocurrencies were even invented). I only know of one site that worked the way you propose: TicketMaster, a long time ago. They used it as a less harsh form of blocking for IPs that they strongly

[Bitcoin-development] Proposal: PoW-based throttling of addresses (was: Outbound connections rotation)

2014-08-20 Thread Isidor Zeuner
Hi there, quote: [...] If two distinct transactions (with unrelated bitcoin addresses) come from the same set of 8 peers, the attacker can conclude that they originated from the same user. This gives another method (in addition to transaction graph analysis) for an attacker to link different

Re: [Bitcoin-development] Proposal: PoW-based throttling of addresses (was: Outbound connections rotation)

2014-08-20 Thread Mike Hearn
Misbehaving addresses can have their connecting difficulty scaled up, which should make it uneconomic to try to DoS the usage of Tor exit nodes for connecting to Bitcoin. You can't solve DoS by requiring all clients to do complicated work, all that means is that weak clients (like users