Re: Brin: A Group Is Its Own Worst Enemy

2003-07-14 Thread Robert J. Chassell
Recently, Clay Shirky wrote an essay on how to create and maintain long-lived groups among people who communicate with each other electronically. Interestingly, although Shirky does not say so specifically, his main focus parallels that of David Brin, who wrote an essay on disputation arenas.

Re: Brin: A Group Is Its Own Worst Enemy

2003-07-14 Thread d.brin
Robert's summery of the group and disputation papers was wonderfully cogent and well-done, worthy of a fine book review or an A+ term paper. As for comparisons with THE CORE... don't just say that you saw em... write em down! Ideally specific, the more the better! Thanks folks. Thrive.

Re: Brin: A Group Is Its Own Worst Enemy

2003-07-05 Thread d.brin
Interesting. But of course nothing new. The reason these boys did what they did is because of lack of accountability. SOme males hold THEMSELVES accountable. But nobody does it perfectly. It's a favor that others will willingly to FOR you. You repay them by (eagerly) returning the

Brin: A Group Is Its Own Worst Enemy

2003-07-04 Thread Jon Gabriel
I've been so incredibly busy with work lately so I've been cutting back on posting Scouted stories to the list. (In fact, from here on in, they'll probably just wind up on my blog instead.) But I thought this might be of as much interest to brinellers as it was to me. It's an essay by Clay