Re: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view.

2004-02-25 Thread Jan Coffey
--- In [EMAIL PROTECTED], Damon Agretto <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > It wasn't even a side claim -I WAS MAKEING- it was > > simply in response > > to that discussion. So, still, if you want > > references for that I know > > you can find them, If you already do not believe > > that then I do

Re: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view.

2004-02-24 Thread Damon Agretto
> It wasn't even a side claim -I WAS MAKEING- it was > simply in response > to that discussion. So, still, if you want > references for that I know > you can find them, If you already do not believe > that then I doubt > you will trust them anyway. I watch a lot of history > channel, > (someti

Re: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view.

2004-02-24 Thread Jan Coffey
--- In [EMAIL PROTECTED], [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: > > > Nah, one post cannot smother a reasonable discussion. The > > fact of the matter is that you have not been successful in > > persuading people to accept some of your main premises. > > > Godwin's Law = 1 a couple of threads ago.. This

Re: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view.

2004-02-24 Thread Jan Coffey
--- In [EMAIL PROTECTED], Steve Sloan II <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Jan Coffey wrote: > > > Dan used a portion of that statment out of context as if I were > > defending Hittler and then reqested citations for that deffence. > > I could easily be wrong, but I read Dan's response as a request

Re: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view.

2004-02-24 Thread Jan Coffey
--- In [EMAIL PROTECTED], Steve Sloan II <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Jan Coffey wrote: > > > Dan used a portion of that statment out of context as if I were > > defending Hittler and then reqested citations for that deffence. > > I could easily be wrong, but I read Dan's response as a request

RE: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view.

2004-02-24 Thread ChadCooper
> Nah, one post cannot smother a reasonable discussion. The > fact of the matter is that you have not been successful in > persuading people to accept some of your main premises. Godwin's Law = 1 a couple of threads ago.. This thread's history... It can't be smothered because its already de

Re: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view.

2004-02-24 Thread Steve Sloan II
Jan Coffey wrote: Dan used a portion of that statment out of context as if I were defending Hittler and then reqested citations for that deffence. I could easily be wrong, but I read Dan's response as a request for evidence that Hitler was appalled at what was going on. I know that was just a si

Re: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view.

2004-02-24 Thread Jan Coffey
--- In [EMAIL PROTECTED], Damon Agretto <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Yahoo, truncated my message, so can't refer to the > original text, but I think the request for citations > in this is entirely reasonable. The statement was made > that there is "evidence that Hitler was appalled by > the Holoca

Re: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view.

2004-02-24 Thread Damon Agretto
Yahoo, truncated my message, so can't refer to the original text, but I think the request for citations in this is entirely reasonable. The statement was made that there is "evidence that Hitler was appalled by the Holocaust" (paraphrased), which goes against any popular view of his objectives. Sa

Re: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view.

2004-02-24 Thread Jan Coffey
--- In [EMAIL PROTECTED], "Dan Minette" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > - Original Message - > From: "Jan Coffey" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: "Killer Bs Discussion" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > Sent: Monday, February 23, 2004 7:41 PM > Subject: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonabl

Re: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view.

2004-02-24 Thread Dan Minette
- Original Message - From: "Jan Coffey" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "Killer Bs Discussion" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Monday, February 23, 2004 7:41 PM Subject: Bitter Mellons, Gin and Tonic, and a an Un- reasonable view. > & other posts on this topic to boot. > > 1) Your doing it again, and