Re: About grub feature

2000-10-09 Thread Alessandro Rubini
Hello Thomas. Grub is currently very PC-specific code. When the project was born the main goal was implementing a boot loader that can work with the several OS's you find in the PC arena, while offering a standardized interface so every OS could follow the specs and be able to be booted by

Bug in stage2 loader (stage2/start.S)

2000-10-09 Thread Herbert Nachtnebel
Title: Bug in stage2 loader (stage2/start.S) To the grub team! If one boots with lba mode enabled, than the routine copy_buffer in stage2/start.S alters the cx register. But the ecx register holds the total number of sectors on disc and the geometry check fails! A bugfix to solve this

[PATCH] setkey fails and causes GRUB to crash.

2000-10-09 Thread Daniel Pittman
It seems that no one must have tried to use the 'setkey' command in GRUB before today. I finally got around to starting to put together my dvorak keymap for it[1], I found a nasty bug. The issues is the table that GRUB uses internally to store the key names, combined with the nature of the

changes for 0.5.96.1

2000-10-09 Thread Gordon Matzigkeit
I am planning to include the following changes in 0.5.96.1 (which we agree is necessary because of the severity of the write_to_partition bug): * Fix for write_to_partition * Fix for grub-install when using a separate /boot partition * Nachtnebel's LBA fix for NO_BUGGY_BIOS_IN_THE_WORLD Do only

Bug#73654: refuses to install

2000-10-09 Thread Wichert Akkerman
Previously Gordon Matzigkeit wrote: I'm about to release 0.5.96... perhaps you could try again with that version and see if it does better? Still doesn't work, but it shows more information: grub find /boot/grub/stage1 (hd0,3) grub root (hd0,3) Filesystem type is ext2fs, partition type

Re: Bug in stage2 loader (stage2/start.S)

2000-10-09 Thread OKUJI Yoshinori
From: Herbert Nachtnebel [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Bug in stage2 loader (stage2/start.S) Date: Mon, 9 Oct 2000 12:24:08 +0200 If one boots with lba mode enabled, than the routine copy_buffer in stage2/start.S alters the cx register. But the ecx register holds the total number of sectors on

Re: Initrd diskless netboot problems

2000-10-09 Thread OKUJI Yoshinori
From: Michael Sullivan [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Initrd diskless netboot problems Date: Mon, 9 Oct 2000 01:10:38 -0400 rdev -R vmlinuz.rd 0 rdev vmlinuz.rd /dev/initrd IIRC, you must set the root device to /dev/ram instead of /dev/initrd. GRUB loads everything fine - both the kernel and

Re: [0.5.96] Error 29: Disk write error, when installing GRUB

2000-10-09 Thread OKUJI Yoshinori
From: Thierry Laronde [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [0.5.96] "Error 29: Disk write error", when installing GRUB Date: Sun, 8 Oct 2000 17:58:16 +0200 Success, but not straightforward. There is a distinction that I do not clearly understand. When one creates a floppy (with a ext2fs), and makes

Re: About grub feature

2000-10-09 Thread Christoph Plattner
A good idea to see in GRUB a protable boot loader. But we have to consider, that workstations for example already have boot monitors with complex functionality, for example handling the system environment. So my idea is, that GRUB should also learn all the addition features of the different

Re: About grub feature

2000-10-09 Thread OKUJI Yoshinori
I comment on the issue a bit. As Christoph pointed out, one of the features in GRUB is that it is (relatively) user-friendly. And, we say, "GRUB is useful for experts like OS developers simultaneously". But is the latter really true? The strategy used in GRUB is to _pass information_ about

Re: grub-install doesn't handle correctly separate /boot partition

2000-10-09 Thread Alessandro Rubini
I think there is another problem with the line shown by Thierry: grubdir_device=`df ${grubdir} | grep /dev/ \ | sed 's%.*\(/dev/[a-z0-9]*\).*%\1%'` The sed expression is wrong as it restricts device names to be lowercase alphanumeric chars. This is a bad assumption. I'd prefer to make no

Re: [0.5.96] Error 29: Disk write error, when installing GRUB

2000-10-09 Thread Thierry Laronde
On Tue, Oct 10, 2000 at 12:56:06AM +0900, OKUJI Yoshinori wrote: From: Thierry Laronde [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [0.5.96] "Error 29: Disk write error", when installing GRUB Date: Sun, 8 Oct 2000 17:58:16 +0200 Success, but not straightforward. There is a distinction that I do not

Re: About grub feature

2000-10-09 Thread Christoph Plattner
I have to say, that I don't know very much of Sun boot monitor, except for that, the I called help and read about the commands on my workstation (Sun SparcStation 5). But what I could see, that it is possible to setup enviornmental settings. This is the only thing I miss under GRUB. On the target

Re: About grub feature

2000-10-09 Thread Thomas T. Soares
OKUJI Yoshinori wrote: ... The strategy used in GRUB is to _pass information_ about hardware and user input data to an OS image, while the strategy used in both Open Firmware and EFI is to _give interfaces_ to access hardware. In other words, GRUB provides higher level interfaces to an

Re: About grub feature

2000-10-09 Thread Gordon Matzigkeit
Christoph Plattner writes: CP But it would be a nice enhancement to support also an environment CP block additional to the command line parameters CP This only should be a "kick" for our design brain CP stroming... this is no requirement ! Figure's O namesystem addresses this issue

passing bootp/dhcp paramters down to kernel?

2000-10-09 Thread Rainer Clasen
Hi! Is there a way to pass the information retrieved via bootp as linux kernel commandline? This would eliminate the need to have linux do bootp itself. Why do I want to avoid this? there is no usable userspace bootp client for linux 2.2.x and there is no way to use the kernel bootp client when

Re: [0.5.96] Error 29: Disk write error, when installing GRUB

2000-10-09 Thread OKUJI Yoshinori
From: Thierry Laronde [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [0.5.96] "Error 29: Disk write error", when installing GRUB Date: Mon, 9 Oct 2000 23:34:04 +0200 For the installation on the MBR, root (hd0,0), setup (hd0) has _not_ taken care of the menu.lst. But the main difference here is that, with the

Re: About grub feature

2000-10-09 Thread OKUJI Yoshinori
From: "Thomas T. Soares" [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: About grub feature Date: Mon, 09 Oct 2000 20:57:21 -0200 It would be nice to know what is EFI... could someone point me a URL about it? http://developer.intel.com/technology/efi/efi.htm Okuji