Re: Using label for Grub root (*not* os root)

2007-02-20 Thread Uwe Dippel
Roger Binns wrote: That is just the same mechanism as labels. Note however that you still need a bootloader that can load the operating system kernel that has the ZFS drivers. Except, they can duplicate. But no need to quarrel here ! In the end, a DHCP-like system might evolve; scanning any

Re: Using label for Grub root (*not* os root)

2007-02-19 Thread Roger Binns
Uwe Dippel wrote: > The logic for hda / sda dies on me too often. My issue is that I frequently add and remove drives from my system. For even more fun, the Linux drivers like to access the drives in a different order than the bios. > On the other hand, I wasted days of my life with labels; I

Re: Using label for Grub root (*not* os root)

2007-02-19 Thread Roger Binns
Jason Thomas wrote: > Everybody, No new functionality will be added to Grub Legacy! I understand. The issue is that the distros all still use Grub Legacy! From the Grub web pages it seems like Grub 2 isn't considered stable yet. So us users are stuck with an unchangeable Grub Legacy and an "un

Re: Using label for Grub root (*not* os root)

2007-02-19 Thread Jason Thomas
Everybody, No new functionality will be added to Grub Legacy! On Mon, Feb 19, 2007 at 01:31:22AM -0800, Roger Binns wrote: > If your patches will end up in the main grub legacy code so that my > distro of choice (Gentoo) will end up picking them up then I'll gladly > do the research about how to

Re: Using label for Grub root (*not* os root)

2007-02-19 Thread Uwe Dippel
Roger Binns wrote: I didn't actually want to use a different (although enhanced) bootloader :-) And I'd much rather use labels than sentinel files. This is going to be a big deal for Linux real soon. The pata drivers are now all handled by the scsi subsystem which just numbers disks in th

Re: Using label for Grub root (*not* os root)

2007-02-19 Thread Roger Binns
adrian15 wrote: > > You may be interested on borrowing the findf command from Super Grub > > Disk source (check dev_grub/stage2/builtins.c ( > > http://supergrub.forjamari.linex.org). I didn't actually want to use a different (although enhanced) bootloader :-) And I'd much rather use labels tha

Re: Using label for Grub root (*not* os root)

2007-02-19 Thread adrian15
Roger Binns escribió: I also considered the "find" command. eg I could put a sentinel file in the correct partition and let Grub search to find that. But I couldn't figure out how to make that part of the normal boot process as above. You may be interested on borrowing the findf command from

Using label for Grub root (*not* os root)

2007-02-18 Thread Roger Binns
Is there any way to specify a filesystem label for Grub, in particular for the root entry? Note that I am not looking for how to do it for my OS - that already works fine. I couldn't find anything in the doc, and past questions seem to have gone unanswered such as this one: http://lists.gnu.org/