Re: Wrongly combined note heads

--On 23 June 2016 09:00 +0200 Simon Albrecht wrote: > With the current behaviour, it's impossible to discern that there > are two different pitches to be played. I first discovered this not from awareness of the actual fault, but because I had an incorrect accidental in

Re: Wrongly combined note heads

"Simon Albrecht" wrote in message news:576b8928.6040...@mail.de... On 23.06.2016 03:16, Andrew Bernard wrote: I think the behaviour you show is normal lilypond semantics - although it is not usually what one wants with different accidentals on the same pitch. I

Re: Wrongly combined note heads

Am 23.06.2016 um 09:19 schrieb Andrew Bernard: > Fixing lilypond would presumably > mean adopting one particular style that may not be what everybody wants. or rather: setting *a default* that not everybody wants. But having to override the default because it's not your preferred way is clearly

Re: Wrongly combined note heads

Hi Simon, What does Elaine Gould say about resolving this? There are a lot of different styles to adopt when faced with this scenario, and although the current lilypond approach is unreadable, you can fix it according to whatever style you prefer. Fixing lilypond would presumably mean adopting

Re: Wrongly combined note heads

On 23.06.2016 03:16, Andrew Bernard wrote: I think the behaviour you show is normal lilypond semantics - although it is not usually what one wants with different accidentals on the same pitch. I believe this is not a bug as it is up to the individual engraver to resolve this according to their

Re: Wrongly combined note heads

Hi Paul, Yo can do this: \version "2.19.42" \language "english" { \clef treble << { \voiceOne g'!4 gs'4 } \new Voice { \voiceTwo gs'4 \once \override NoteColumn.force-hshift = #1 g'!4 } >> } I think the behaviour you show is normal lilypond

Wrongly combined note heads

> I'm not top posting. % Note heads in different voices are combined % even though they have different accidentals \version "2.19.42" \language "english" << { g'4 gs'4 } \\ { gs'4 g'4 } >> Result: https://cassland.org/images/PWH-wrongly-combined-noteheads.png