Re: [Bug-tar] adding ACLs when there are none

2014-03-05 Thread Pavel Raiskup
Hello Linda, On Tuesday, March 04, 2014 15:38:22 Linda A. Walsh wrote: Pavel Raiskup wrote: When --acls option is on (regardless of tarball contents or tarball format), we should explicitly set OR delete default ACLs for extracted directories. Prior to this update, we always created

Re: [Bug-tar] adding ACLs when there are none

2014-03-05 Thread Linda Walsh
Pavel Raiskup wrote: These are IMO candidates for omitting --acls option, no? Or could you give an example? What *exactly* do you expect the --acls should behave by default? Combine existing acls in parent directory (default acls) with the stored in archive? Leaving default acls in the dir

Re: [Bug-tar] adding ACLs when there are none

2014-03-05 Thread Linda A. Walsh
Pavel Raiskup wrote: Or could you give an example? What *exactly* do you expect the --acls should behave by default? Combine existing acls in parent directory (default acls) with the stored in archive? Thanks, Pavel - Sorry, didn't finish that thought...If there are default acls set

Re: [Bug-tar] adding ACLs when there are none

2014-03-05 Thread Pavel Raiskup
On Wednesday, March 05, 2014 05:06:06 Linda A. Walsh wrote: Pavel Raiskup wrote: Or could you give an example? What *exactly* do you expect the --acls should behave by default? Combine existing acls in parent directory (default acls) with the stored in archive? Thanks, Pavel -

Re: [Bug-tar] adding ACLs when there are none

2014-03-05 Thread Joerg Schilling
Pavel Raiskup prais...@redhat.com wrote: On Wednesday, March 05, 2014 05:06:06 Linda A. Walsh wrote: Pavel Raiskup wrote: Or could you give an example? What *exactly* do you expect the --acls should behave by default? Combine existing acls in parent directory (default acls) with the

Re: [Bug-tar] adding ACLs when there are none

2014-03-04 Thread Linda A. Walsh
Pavel Raiskup wrote: When --acls option is on (regardless of tarball contents or tarball format), we should explicitly set OR delete default ACLs for extracted directories. Prior to this update, we always created arbitrary default ACLs based standard file permissions. Why would tar