Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-07 Thread David Holmes
On 7/09/2012 11:15 PM, Andrew Hughes wrote: On 6/09/2012 1:00 AM, Andrew Hughes wrote: Should .diz files be removed when packaging JDK/JRE for Linux ? Specifically talking about packaging, distro build systems already handle stripping, etc. themselves so we've been setting STRIP_POLICY=no_st

Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-07 Thread Andrew Hughes
- Original Message - > Andrew, > > On 6/09/2012 1:00 AM, Andrew Hughes wrote: > > - Original Message - > >> Interesting point. > >> > >> Should .diz files be removed when packaging JDK/JRE for Linux ? > >> > > > > Specifically talking about packaging, distro build systems already

Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-05 Thread David Holmes
On 6/09/2012 12:00 AM, Daniel D. Daugherty wrote: On 9/5/12 4:46 AM, David Holmes wrote: Dan, Sorry, not meaning to ruffle your feathers. Not ruffled. Just very tired of FDS. Understood. Thanks for your patience and forbearance. :) If the libraries are removed from the image, then that sa

Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-05 Thread David Holmes
Andrew, On 6/09/2012 1:00 AM, Andrew Hughes wrote: - Original Message - Interesting point. Should .diz files be removed when packaging JDK/JRE for Linux ? Specifically talking about packaging, distro build systems already handle stripping, etc. themselves so we've been setting STRIP

Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-05 Thread Andrew Hughes
- Original Message - > Interesting point. > > Should .diz files be removed when packaging JDK/JRE for Linux ? > Specifically talking about packaging, distro build systems already handle stripping, etc. themselves so we've been setting STRIP_POLICY=no_strip. However, this still creates th

Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-05 Thread Daniel D. Daugherty
On 9/5/12 4:46 AM, David Holmes wrote: Dan, Sorry, not meaning to ruffle your feathers. Not ruffled. Just very tired of FDS. The reason I say the diz-in-image story is unclear is because there are no explicit rules that indicates that diz files should end up in a JDK or JRE image. I can ac

Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-05 Thread Andrew Haley
On 09/05/2012 01:02 PM, Henri Gomez wrote: > Interesting point. > > Should .diz files be removed when packaging JDK/JRE for Linux ? I would have thought that depended on whether this is OpenJDK or proprietary JDK. For OpenJDK, surely the debuginfo should be in all builds. We do want people to b

Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-05 Thread Henri Gomez
Interesting point. Should .diz files be removed when packaging JDK/JRE for Linux ? 2012/9/5 David Holmes : > Dan, > > Sorry, not meaning to ruffle your feathers. > > The reason I say the diz-in-image story is unclear is because there are no > explicit rules that indicates that diz files should en

Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-05 Thread David Holmes
Dan, Sorry, not meaning to ruffle your feathers. The reason I say the diz-in-image story is unclear is because there are no explicit rules that indicates that diz files should end up in a JDK or JRE image. I can accept that everything should go in a full JDK image. But a JRE is a JDK with a b

Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-04 Thread Daniel D. Daugherty
On 9/2/12 9:37 PM, David Holmes wrote: Hi Dan, On 3/09/2012 12:47 PM, Daniel D. Daugherty wrote: On 9/2/12 7:26 PM, David Holmes wrote: The build will create debuginfo/diz files as requested - that's fine. What I'm unclear about is where those files should actually appear in our build artifac

Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-02 Thread David Holmes
Hi Dan, On 3/09/2012 12:47 PM, Daniel D. Daugherty wrote: On 9/2/12 7:26 PM, David Holmes wrote: The build will create debuginfo/diz files as requested - that's fine. What I'm unclear about is where those files should actually appear in our build artifacts, specifically the jdk/jre images that

Re: debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-02 Thread Daniel D. Daugherty
On 9/2/12 7:26 PM, David Holmes wrote: The build will create debuginfo/diz files as requested - that's fine. What I'm unclear about is where those files should actually appear in our build artifacts, specifically the jdk/jre images that are created. Internally when we create binary images RE

debuginfo/diz files in built images

2012-09-02 Thread David Holmes
The build will create debuginfo/diz files as requested - that's fine. What I'm unclear about is where those files should actually appear in our build artifacts, specifically the jdk/jre images that are created. Internally when we create binary images RE strips all the debuginfo/diz files out.