[Cake] Cake on elements of a bridge

2018-09-04 Thread Georgios Amanakis
Dear All, I was giving a transparent firewall a try, and wondered whether cake can be applied on the interfaces of a bridge. I want to put an extra router in-line between clients and the ISP-modem-router. It will have two interfaces (eth0 facing wan, eth1 facing lan), bridged together as br0. Can

Re: [Cake] Cake on elements of a bridge

2018-09-04 Thread Toke Høiland-Jørgensen
Georgios Amanakis writes: > Dear All, > > I was giving a transparent firewall a try, and wondered whether cake > can be applied on the interfaces of a bridge. I want to put an extra > router in-line between clients and the ISP-modem-router. It will have > two interfaces (eth0 facing wan, eth1 fac

Re: [Cake] Cake on elements of a bridge

2018-09-04 Thread Georgios Amanakis
Awesome, thanks to both of you! I am aware of the uselessness of nat (in terms of cake) in this setup. It's good to know what Sebastian pointed out. I ran it for a couple of hours and it seems to be working fine. I am going to finalize the setup and will get back to you. Georgios On 4 Sep 2018 1:

[Cake] Fwd: Cake on elements of a bridge

2018-09-04 Thread Sebastian Moeller
Dear All, again I sent privately what should have been on the list. Now, this does not add much to Toke's response, but since Georgios referenced it it seems doubly awkward to keep it off-list... Best Regards Sebastian > Begin forwarded message: > > From: Sebastian Moeller > Subject

[Cake] dug up this old paper

2018-09-04 Thread Dave Taht
I am increasingly agreeing that as we scale past 100s of mbit, that what they say increasingly applies http://yuba.stanford.edu/techreports/TR04-HPNG-060800.pdf -- Dave Täht CEO, TekLibre, LLC http://www.teklibre.com Tel: 1-669-226-2619 ___ Cake mailin

[Cake] apu2 sqm/htb issue + a minor win for speeding up fq_codel itself

2018-09-04 Thread Dave Taht
less than scientifically (via monitoring top) - on the apu2 100Mbit sqm (htb + fq_codel) fq_codel_mainline | fq_codel_fast idle 78.8| 83.5 | si20 | 16.1 | Yea! But: 900Mbit sqm (htb + fq_codel) fq_codel_mainline | fq_codel_fast idle 74.4| 7

Re: [Cake] apu2 sqm/htb issue + a minor win for speeding up fq_codel itself

2018-09-04 Thread Dave Taht
making htb's cburst and burst parameters 64k gets the APU2 up to where it can shape 900mbits. 3 ksoftirq handlers start getting cpu time, and we end up 54% idle to achiefe that. I should really go around running my own old code. I was deeply involved in sqm when we still had to run at sub 200mbit

Re: [Cake] apu2 sqm/htb issue + a minor win for speeding up fq_codel itself

2018-09-04 Thread Dave Taht
my guess is that burst and cburst should scale roughly as a function of the bytes that can fit into 1ms. On Tue, Sep 4, 2018 at 2:14 PM Dave Taht wrote: > > making htb's cburst and burst parameters 64k gets the APU2 up to > where it can shape 900mbits. 3 ksoftirq handlers start getting cpu > time