Re: How about using real HTML templates for Form input fields?

2011-11-04 Thread AD7six
On Nov 4, 2:47 am, Miles J mileswjohn...@gmail.com wrote: Ive always wanted this. Cakes defaults are pretty handy but once you want to break out of the norm it gets tedious. I would also change the HTML structure but thats just me :P @Sherlock - There's not much overhead in doing a basic

Re: How about using real HTML templates for Form input fields?

2011-11-04 Thread majna
@sams and @AD7six Yes, one element for each input. Performance is not issue here. Finally, you can cache those elements as any other View::element() calls. This is not only about applying Twitter Bootstrap. FormHelper is not flexible enough and extending large methods is not best solution.

Re: How about using real HTML templates for Form input fields?

2011-11-04 Thread AD7six
On Nov 4, 11:41 am, majna majna...@gmail.com wrote: @sams and @AD7six Yes, one element for each input. Performance is not issue here. Finally, you can cache those elements as any other View::element() calls. Try what you're suggesting and benchmark it before dismissing performance -

How about using real HTML templates for Form input fields?

2011-11-03 Thread majna
Instead of using array based options for FormHelper inputs like: label, before, after, div, format etc. maybe HTML templates would be more friendly and easier to customize. For each input type there will be one Cake element as template. Here is an example, a proof of concept on how it may look

Re: How about using real HTML templates for Form input fields?

2011-11-03 Thread Sam Sherlock
So you'd get increased flexiblity (in markup control) but at what cost. additional overhead (an element for each form input) and having to make a range of elements for various differing situations or maybe I am missing the point - I am certain that you can do this without the need to call a Cake

Re: How about using real HTML templates for Form input fields?

2011-11-03 Thread 100rk
Those templates could be theme specific (like Twitter Bootstrap) and IMHO only not-so-easy solvable problem with Twitter Bootstrap and cake forms is - label wrapped around checkboxes, for both single-ones and 'multiple' (wrapped in unordered lists). Rest of it is easy, thanks to 'className' key

Re: How about using real HTML templates for Form input fields?

2011-11-03 Thread Miles J
Ive always wanted this. Cakes defaults are pretty handy but once you want to break out of the norm it gets tedious. I would also change the HTML structure but thats just me :P @Sherlock - There's not much overhead in doing a basic PHP include. On Nov 3, 6:21 pm, 100rk lubomir.st...@gmail.com

Re: How about using real HTML templates for Form input fields?

2011-11-03 Thread LunarDraco
In 2.0 you solve this tedious by building/subclassing formhelper. Using the alias feature and writing your own functions to support your needed/different template and format. On Nov 3, 7:47 pm, Miles J mileswjohn...@gmail.com wrote: Ive always wanted this. Cakes defaults are pretty handy but