On Wed, May 2, 2018 at 10:06 PM Michael Richardson
wrote:
> Have we considered TCP RST already? (I don't think it's better than ICMP,
but
> I don't remember it being discussed yet)
We can now if you like. But not all protocols use TCP.
David (Bird) listed some of the things that are in common u
Martin Thomson wrote:
> The form of that signal is next to consider. We have discussed ICMP
> DestUnreach with a both new and existing codes. The feedback in London
was
> that maybe DestUnreach has some downsides and a new message would be
> better. A new ICMP message would al
Just to reiterate what Erik said here. Based on the discussion in London
we have a better (but not perfect) understanding of what a signal would
need to look like. But until we have a concrete proposal that fits the
requirements, all we have is a liability. As a chair, I'm interested in us
compl
