Re: [ccp4bb] Zinc or Iron binding protein, that is a question!

2009-08-09 Thread Xuan Yang
Dear Marius, I checked out the references, and it was mentioned that The zinc EXAFS spectra of P. shermanii superoxide dismutase have shown that zinc can be incorporated in the active center instead of the iron. (Eur. Biophys. J. * 24* , 243-250). And this example further aroused my concern

Re: [ccp4bb] Zinc or Iron binding protein, that is a question!

2009-08-06 Thread Guenter Fritz
Hi Xuan, I guess your protein is not an E.coli protein. There are several examples that eukaryotic Zn-proteins expressed in E.coli contain Fe instead of Zn. I am sceptic whether IMAC with different metal ions will give the solution of the problem. If you really want to get information on the

Re: [ccp4bb] Zinc or Iron binding protein, that is a question!

2009-08-06 Thread George M. Sheldrick
Since you sent your question to CCP4bb you presumably have crystals! In that case an excellent way to check which metal atoms you have in which sites is to collect datasets at a synchrotron at suitably chosen wavelengths and look at the anomalous maps. For an example see Acta Cryst. D62 (2006)

Re: [ccp4bb] Zinc or Iron binding protein, that is a question!

2009-08-06 Thread Xuan Yang
Dear Mr. Fritz, Yes, the protein is not an E.coli protein! Instead, it was cloned from a virus. And since it was a nonstructural viral protein, I thought it might be appropiate to treat it as eukaryotic proteins. E.coli system was quite different from eukaryotic ones, hence I was quite cautious

Re: [ccp4bb] Zinc or Iron binding protein, that is a question!

2009-08-06 Thread Marius Schmidt
Long time ago I had a superoxide dismutase that was active with iron as well as manganese. No matter what functional metal (Fe or Mn) was bound a substantial fraction up to 1/3 of the molecules had the (non-functional) Zinc in their metal binding site (found by AAS and EXAFS). Zinc is

Re: [ccp4bb] Zinc or Iron binding protein, that is a question!

2009-08-06 Thread Roger Rowlett
As others have implied, quantifying metals in metalloproteins is very challenging. In my experience, the principal problems are (1) adventitious metal contamination, (2) accurate measurement of protein concentration, and (3) weak metal binding. Zinc and iron are ubiquitous microcontaminants,

[ccp4bb] Zinc or Iron binding protein, that is a question!

2009-08-05 Thread Xuan Yang
Dear Sir or Madam, The ICP-ES results indicated that 1 molar my protein purified from E.coli Origami(DE3) contained about a half molar Zinc and nearly a quarter molar Iron (whether II or III was not available). The protein carried a MBP tag on the N-terminal and the situation was similar with or