Re: [ccp4bb] seeding, reproducibility

2014-01-18 Thread Patrick Shaw Stewart
One or more ingredients in the original hit (which you use to suspend the seed crystals in) can indeed be essential, and may be all you need to get nice crystals. In D'Arcy's original paper you will see that he needed Ca2+ to get nice crystals of one of his proteins. The same is true in

Re: [ccp4bb] seeding, reproducibility

2014-01-17 Thread Matthias Zebisch
Dear Mahesh, cross-seeding into other conditions often works but still the chances are much lower than seeding the same form. Best wishes, Matthias (Please desist from sending so large attachments to half the planet!) - Dr. Matthias Zebisch Division

Re: [ccp4bb] seeding, reproducibility

2014-01-17 Thread Patrick Shaw Stewart
Mahesh, this is a very interesting and slightly controversial question. One approach is to mix together all of the crystals that you have in the initial screen. The idea at the beginning of the project is to get as many diverse hits as possible - you can worry about crystal size, space group and

Re: [ccp4bb] seeding, reproducibility

2014-01-17 Thread Mahesh Lingaraju
Thanks you for the suggestions, Patrick and Matthias. I was actually wondering if any of the components from the seeding solution actually were important but your explanations sound more logical. I apologize for the large attachment. I did not realize that it was so big. Have a nice weekend !