[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-04-04 Thread Brent Kennedy
I think I may have cheated... I setup the ceph iscsi gateway in HA mode, then a freenas server. Connected the freenas server to the iscsi targets and poof, I have a universal NFS share(s). I stood up a few freenas servers to share various loads. We also use the iscsi gateways for direct esxi

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-03-16 Thread Konstantin Shalygin
On 3/16/20 4:10 PM, mj wrote: Just out of curiosity: We are currently running a samba server with RBD disks as a VM on our proxmox/ceph cluster. I see the advantage of having vfs_ceph_snapshots of the samba user-data. But then again: re-sharing data using samba vfs_ceph adds a layer of comp

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-03-16 Thread mj
On 3/16/20 5:21 AM, Konstantin Shalygin wrote: On 3/13/20 8:49 PM, Marc Roos wrote: Can you also create snapshots via the vfs_ceph solution? Yes! Since Samba 4.11 this supported via vfs_ceph_snapshots module. Just out of curiosity: We are currently running a samba server with RBD disks a

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-03-15 Thread Konstantin Shalygin
On 3/14/20 3:08 AM, Seth Galitzer wrote: Thanks to all who have offered advise on this. I have been looking at using vfs_ceph in samba, but I'm unsure how to get it on Centos7. As I understand it, it's optional at compile time. When searching for a package for it, I see one glusterfs (samba-vfs

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-03-15 Thread Konstantin Shalygin
On 3/13/20 8:49 PM, Marc Roos wrote: Can you also create snapshots via the vfs_ceph solution? Yes! Since Samba 4.11 this supported via vfs_ceph_snapshots module. k ___ ceph-users mailing list -- ceph-users@ceph.io To unsubscribe send an email to ce

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway? (Marc Roos)

2020-03-14 Thread Martin Verges
Hello Chad, starting with the Problems from lost connections with the kernel CephFS mount to a much simpler service setup, there are plenty. But what would be the point in stacking different tools (kernel mount, smb service,..) untested together just because you can? -- Martin Verges Managing dir

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-03-14 Thread Konstantin Shalygin
On 3/13/20 10:47 PM, Chip Cox wrote: Konstantin - in your Windows environment, would it be beneficial to have the ability to have NTFS data land as S3 (object store) on a Ceph storage appliance?  Or does it have to be NFS? Thanks and look forward to hearing back. Nope, for windows we use Cep

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-03-13 Thread Seth Galitzer
Thanks to all who have offered advise on this. I have been looking at using vfs_ceph in samba, but I'm unsure how to get it on Centos7. As I understand it, it's optional at compile time. When searching for a package for it, I see one glusterfs (samba-vfs-glusterfs), but nothing for ceph. Is it

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway? (Marc Roos)

2020-03-13 Thread Chad William Seys
Awhile back I thought there were some limitations which prevented us from trying this, but I cannot remember... What does the ceph vfs gain you over exporting by cephfs kernel module (kernel 4.19). What does it lose you? (I.e. pros and cons versus kernel module?) Thanks! C. It's based on v

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-03-13 Thread Marc Roos
Can you also create snapshots via the vfs_ceph solution? -Original Message- Sent: 13 March 2020 14:46 Subject: [ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway? Hello, we have a CTDB based HA Samba in our Ceph Management Solution. It works like a charm and we

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-03-13 Thread Martin Verges
Hello, we have a CTDB based HA Samba in our Ceph Management Solution. It works like a charm and we connect it to existing active directories as well. It's based on vfs_ceph and you can read more about how to configure it yourself on https://www.samba.org/samba/docs/current/man-html/vfs_ceph.8.htm

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-03-13 Thread Nathan Fish
Note that we have had issues with deadlocks when re-exporting CephFS via Samba. It appears to only occur with Mac clients, though. In some cases it has hung on a request for a high-level directory and hung that branch for all clients. On Fri, Mar 13, 2020 at 1:56 AM Konstantin Shalygin wrote: > >

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-03-12 Thread Rafael Lopez
Hi Seth, I don't know if this helps you, but I'll share what we do. We present a large amount of CephFS using NFS and SMB and a handful of cephfs direct clients, and rarely encounter issues with either frontends or CephFS. However, the 'gateway' is multiple servers - we use 2x ganesha servers wi

[ceph-users] Re: Is there a better way to make a samba/nfs gateway?

2020-03-12 Thread Konstantin Shalygin
On 3/11/20 11:16 PM, Seth Galitzer wrote: I have a hybrid environment and need to share with both Linux and Windows clients. For my previous iterations of file storage, I exported nfs and samba shares directly from my monolithic file server. All Linux clients used nfs and all Windows clients