[ceph-users] Re: understanding orchestration and cephadm

2021-04-05 Thread Gary Molenkamp
Thanks Sage, I opted to move to an explicit placement map of candidate hostnames and a replica count rather than using labels.  This is a testing cluster of VMs to experiment before updating the production system. The only reason I was starting with 2 on the test cluster is that my

[ceph-users] Re: understanding orchestration and cephadm

2021-03-31 Thread Sage Weil
Hi Gary, It looks like everything you did is fine. I think the "problem" is that cephadm has/had some logic that tried to leave users with an odd number of monitors. I'm pretty sure this is why two of them were removed. This code has been removed in pacific, and should probably be backported

[ceph-users] Re: understanding orchestration and cephadm

2021-03-31 Thread Philip Brown
Yoo have conflated "ceph orch host add" and "ceph orch host label add" This is not valid syntax: ceph orch host add osdev-ctrl3 mon The docs imply that the trailing "mon" would be ignored, since there is no 6th argument to that command.