Re: [CF-metadata] CF Convention - standard_names

2011-05-27 Thread Karl Taylor
Hi Glenn, My reading of the conformance document (as well as the conventions document) is that standard_name is optional (but either standard_name or long_name is recommended). Here's the relevant section from the conformance document: 3 Description of the Data *Recommendations: *

Re: [CF-metadata] CF Convention - standard_names

2011-05-27 Thread Nan Galbraith
Hi Glenn - Given that this would greatly undermine the purpose of the CF Convention, On the contrary, it's very important that variables without standard names be allowed in CF files. In OceanSITES, we use this "feature" of the convention to allow users to include instrument-specific and prove

[CF-metadata] CF Convention - standard_names

2011-05-27 Thread Comiskey, Glenn
Hi, I note a discrepency between the CF document and the CF conformance requirements and recommendations document, for all versions v1.0 thru v1.5, in that the CF conformance requirements and recommendations document states that the standard_name attribute is a requirement, while the CF document