Re: [CF-metadata] Usage of the 'Conventions' attribute (Nan Galbraith)

2013-01-28 Thread Lowry, Roy K.
Dear Jonathan and Martin, What I was trying to do here was legitimise an already established practice in at least two communities in the observational oceanographic domain with thousands of files in existence with the non-standard usage of the Conventions attribute. I also carried the practice

Re: [CF-metadata] Usage of the 'Conventions' attribute

2013-01-28 Thread Bentley, Philip
Roy et al., > Martin's comments on namespace highlight a concern I > identified whilst doing the research for the SeaDataNet > specification. Several communities have added large numbers > of both global and variable attributes with no indication of > namespace. Not only does this make it d

Re: [CF-metadata] Usage of the 'Conventions' attribute

2013-01-28 Thread David Hassell
Hello Phil, > But, assuming these could be resolved, what do people think about > use of '.' as a namespace separator? Good idea? Bad idea? > > Some recent postings to this list have suggested using a 'cf_' > prefix, with the implied suggestion of a '_' namespace > separator. IMHO, this approach

Re: [CF-metadata] Proposal for new standard_names for biomass burning emissions

2013-01-28 Thread alison.pamment
Dear Martin and Angelika, Thank you for your proposals. Thank you also to Philip and Jonathan for their useful comments in the discussion of these names. I think the molecular hydrogen and dimethyl sulphate names are unproblematic and well defined. The following four names are accepted for incl

Re: [CF-metadata] Usage of the 'Conventions' attribute

2013-01-28 Thread Dennis Heimbigner
With respect to netcdf (at least the C version), it is the case that these characters can appear unescaped: _.@+- It should be noted however that dot in particular causes problems for accessing remote datasets through DAP because the dot character is used in DAP constraints to specify fields ins

Re: [CF-metadata] Usage of the 'Conventions' attribute

2013-01-28 Thread Nan Galbraith
Any of these special characters, other than the '_', would probably cause problems for code that deals with NetCDF files. The '.' is used in Matlab for access to structures, and the '@' is used to identify a variable as a function handle. There are work-arounds, but they likely wouldn't add effici

Re: [CF-metadata] Usage of the 'Conventions' attribute

2013-01-28 Thread Lowry, Roy K.
Hi Nan, Would the CF web site be an appropriate place for communities to post the attributes they have added to CF - either with or without namespace prefixes? Cheers, Roy. From: CF-metadata [cf-metadata-boun...@cgd.ucar.edu] On Behalf Of Nan Galbraith