Re: [CF-metadata] Trac forwarding to mailing list

2017-10-25 Thread Brian Eaton
Hi All, An extra bit of info on this. The trac and mailman lists are indeed independent. They are synchronized by hand. As moderator of the cf-metadata mailman list I keep a list of new subscriptions and removals from the list and every now and then I forward that list to folks at PCMDI. So wh

Re: [CF-metadata] Trac forwarding to mailing list

2017-10-25 Thread Dave Allured - NOAA Affiliate
All, A couple people confirmed to me that Trac forwarding is currently working as intended. Thanks Jeff and Karl. The tricky thing is that Trac messages bypass the Mailman process, so they don't go into the Mailman archive, or receive the Mailman footer lines. Sorry for the extra noise, but I a

Re: [CF-metadata] various "time" in CF

2017-10-25 Thread Chris Barker
On Wed, Oct 25, 2017 at 8:57 AM, Sebastien Villaume < sebastien.villa...@ecmwf.int> wrote: > @Chris, thanks for your contribution to the discussion. very interesting > > I don't agree with your comment regarding 3D data variable with 4 > coordinates being wrong. I have 3 physical axes and 4 coord

[CF-metadata] Trac forwarding to mailing list

2017-10-25 Thread Dave Allured - NOAA Affiliate
Jonathan, Thanks for mentioning this. It is difficult for the ticket creator to confirm broadcast of a new ticket message. I am not sure whether the new ticket confirmation that I received was broadcast or a private reply, but I notice that the Mailman list trailer is absent. This indicates pri

[CF-metadata] [Use GitHub instead Trac proposal] CF Conventions 1.7 is released

2017-10-25 Thread Jonathan Gregory
Dear Antonio Jeff Painter is working on the distribution of GitHub postings to the email list, as we have at the moment from trac, so that everyone is kept informed. Once that is in place, I will make a further proposal on the ticket. Best wishes Jonathan - Forwarded message from "Antonio S

Re: [CF-metadata] various "time" in CF

2017-10-25 Thread Sebastien Villaume
Dear Jonathan, Chris and other, @Chris, thanks for your contribution to the discussion. very interesting I don't agree with your comment regarding 3D data variable with 4 coordinates being wrong. I have 3 physical axes and 4 coordinates, yes, but leadtime is a coordinates associated to the same

Re: [CF-metadata] [Use GitHub instead Trac proposal] CF Conventions 1.7 is released

2017-10-25 Thread Antonio S . Cofiño
Hi @Jonathan, What is the status of  the proposal to move from Trac to GitHub? https://cf-trac.llnl.gov/trac/ticket/160 Antonio On 08/09/17 14:36, Jonathan Gregory wrote: Dear Jeff Thanks for the announcement and for your own great and painstaking efforts over producing CF 1.7. It's great to

Re: [CF-metadata] various "time" in CF

2017-10-25 Thread Jonathan Gregory
Dear Sebastien and Chris The various ways to handle forecast times, analysis times and forecast periods with multiple time axes have been discussed several times before. Since there are plenty of use-cases, and it's complicated, it would be good if we could agree on recommended ways to do it, whic

[CF-metadata] Use of valid_range etc. to indicate unsigned integers

2017-10-25 Thread Jonathan Gregory
Dear Dave > I did not realize that new tickets are > not automatically sent to the CF general mailing list. They *should* be sent to everyone, if the system is working as intended. Best wishes Jonathan ___ CF-metadata mailing list CF-metadata@cgd.ucar