[CF-metadata] Multiple file datasets

2009-11-24 Thread Jonathan Gregory
Dear John > Do we use "cross referencing variables" just in the "coordinates" > attribute or are there other places? There are several of them apart from coordinates: variables are named by cell_measures (as Balaji mentioned), formula_terms, ancillary_variables, bounds, climatology, grid_mapping

Re: [CF-metadata] Multiple file datasets

2009-11-23 Thread John Caron
Hi Jonathan, Steve, et al: Question: Do we use "cross referencing variables" just in the "coordinates" attribute or are there other places? Comment: Not having the files explicitly named means that the collection of files is defined externally. NcML does this, as apparently does the cdms c

[CF-metadata] Multiple file datasets

2009-11-22 Thread Jonathan Gregory
Dear all Using metadata to describe a file internally is much more robust than encoding filenames in a file, and therefore seems preferable to me. I am concerned that the gridspec proposal suggests using relative filenames in an attribute in the file (associate_files). If I understand correctly, t

Re: [CF-metadata] Multiple file datasets

2009-11-20 Thread Steve Hankin
(My apologies for a rushed answer ... proposal deadlines today.) The CF group discussed this topic at length in the context of how to infer membership in a model ensemble: how can CF make it evident that one model run is a close cousin of another's? The basic strategy that emerged from those

Re: [CF-metadata] Multiple file datasets

2009-11-20 Thread John Caron
Stephen Emsley wrote: Can anyone summarize what SAFE does? I will give it a shot as I brought it up in the first place! The Standard Archive Format for Europe (SAFE) was developed as a common format for archiving to ensure long-term preservation of EO data holdings, both historical and opera

Re: [CF-metadata] Multiple file datasets (was: Swath observational data)

2009-11-20 Thread V. Balaji
The gridspec indeed had a proposal about this. Clearly it was a bit off-topic, but some mechanism of referring to other files was needed. It consists of an attribute called a link_spec, which has attributes of a baseURL, a relative pathname, and a checksum for verifying whether the external file b

Re: [CF-metadata] Multiple file datasets (was: Swath observational data)

2009-11-20 Thread Stephen Emsley
(0)7912 515 418 -Original Message- From: cf-metadata-boun...@cgd.ucar.edu [mailto:cf-metadata-boun...@cgd.ucar.edu] On Behalf Of John Caron Sent: 20 November 2009 12:30 To: cf-metadata@cgd.ucar.edu Subject: [CF-metadata] Multiple file datasets (was: Swath observational data) This topic

Re: [CF-metadata] Multiple file datasets (was: Swath observational data)

2009-11-20 Thread Stephen Emsley
cf-metadata-boun...@cgd.ucar.edu [mailto:cf-metadata-boun...@cgd.ucar.edu] On Behalf Of John Caron Sent: 20 November 2009 12:30 To: cf-metadata@cgd.ucar.edu Subject: [CF-metadata] Multiple file datasets (was: Swath observational data) This topic deserves its own heading, so here it is. Perhaps

[CF-metadata] Multiple file datasets (was: Swath observational data)

2009-11-20 Thread John Caron
This topic deserves its own heading, so here it is. Perhaps we should gather current practices and ideas. I think Balaji's gridspec has a proposal about this. Can anyone summarize what SAFE does? Im imagining how this is actually used, eg: float data(y,x); data:coordinates = "l...@file1 l...@