Re: [CF-metadata] support for multiple auxulary coordinate variables

2012-09-05 Thread Jim Biard
Hi. The new grid_mapping scheme looks great! It accomplishes, in a more backward compatible way, most of the things that I was suggesting. Regarding Jonathan's reply to my previous comment: If I read a temperature using a thermometer, the value does not have a geographic coordinate system asso

[CF-metadata] support for multiple auxulary coordinate variables

2012-09-05 Thread Jonathan Gregory
Dear Randy I agree with what you write. You could list the alternative sets of three coordinates each all as auxiliary coord vars, and distinguish them with standard_names; presumably you would want to propose some new standard_names. That would be fine and quite simple to do. In addition, you co

Re: [CF-metadata] support for multiple auxulary coordinate variables

2012-09-05 Thread Jim Biard
Hi. The issue you are raising regarding coordinate systems and the grid_mapping attribute is something I have been wondering about lately. Doesn't the grid_mapping attribute more properly reside on the coordinate (or auxiliary coordinate) variable? Strictly speaking, the data values don't hav

Re: [CF-metadata] support for multiple auxulary coordinate variables

2012-09-03 Thread Randy Horne
There is one thing I forgot to mention. The CF conventions support grid mappings.Conceptually, grid mappings exist for these space weather products. For example, J2000 is a specific type of earth centered inertial coordinate system. Similarly, "body reference frame" can be viewed as bein

Re: [CF-metadata] support for multiple auxulary coordinate variables

2012-09-03 Thread Randy Horne
Jonathan: Thanks for the follow-up ! I am currently working level 1b space weather products. These products are derived from instruments in orbit. These instruments have have one or more sensing apertures that point out into space. these instruments sniff for energetic particles. The field

[CF-metadata] support for multiple auxulary coordinate variables

2012-09-03 Thread Jonathan Gregory
Dear Randy > I have a situation where there is value in including multiple auxiliary > coordinate variablles for the same data variable. Specifically, I would like > to communicate that there are two distinct three dimensional cartesian > coordinates for each data value. > > Do the current CF

[CF-metadata] support for multiple auxulary coordinate variables

2012-08-27 Thread Randy Horne
Folks: I have a situation where there is value in including multiple auxiliary coordinate variablles for the same data variable. Specifically, I would like to communicate that there are two distinct three dimensional cartesian coordinates for each data value. Do the current CF conventions pro