[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-07-13 Thread Evan Martin
On Mon, Jul 13, 2009 at 9:55 AM, Glen Murphy wrote: >> Actually, I take that back.  I could swear they did, but I am >> evidently wrong (after just checking a few). >> >> Never mind :-). > > I believe some used to - the context menu entry was going to be our > foreground-opening UI, but lots of pe

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-07-13 Thread Glen Murphy
> Actually, I take that back.  I could swear they did, but I am > evidently wrong (after just checking a few). > > Never mind :-). I believe some used to - the context menu entry was going to be our foreground-opening UI, but lots of people use it and expect background-opening. --~--~-~-

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-07-13 Thread Peter Kasting
On Mon, Jul 13, 2009 at 9:21 AM, Amanda Walker wrote: > --Amanda > (who still prefers foreground tabs, but will just resort to "open in > new window" instead) Shift-middle or shift-control click. (All browsers I've tested support this.) PK --~--~-~--~~~---~--~

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-07-13 Thread Amanda Walker
Actually, I take that back. I could swear they did, but I am evidently wrong (after just checking a few). Never mind :-). --Amanda (who still prefers foreground tabs, but will just resort to "open in new window" instead) On Mon, Jul 13, 2009 at 12:19 PM, Amanda Walker wrote: > On Fri, Jun 26,

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-07-13 Thread Amanda Walker
On Fri, Jun 26, 2009 at 8:22 PM, Peter Kasting wrote: > Given that there are a large number of ways to open the home page in a new > foreground tab (e.g. ctrl-t + click, shift-middle click, etc.), there are a > very large number of other places in the UI where middle-click opens a new > background

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-06-29 Thread Itai
Yes, it can also close tabs. I meant to emphasis the _background_ part of the operation. It also opens _in_the_background_. When it closes a tab, it closes it in the background too ;) - Itai On Jun 29, 10:01 am, Mike Pinkerton wrote: > > Middle-click always opens a new tab in the background an

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-06-29 Thread Mike Pinkerton
> Middle-click always opens a new tab in the background and making > exceptions is just likely to confuse users. Except when middle-clicking on a tab means "close the tab". So it means both open and close, depending on the context. -- Mike Pinkerton Mac Weenie pinker...@google.com --~--~--

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-06-29 Thread Itai
@krtumay: I think you are confused now. Evan was asking about the Home button (which optionally appears in the navigation bar, next to reload). NTP can also be opened in the foreground as a new tab using the small '+" icon. The '+' actually does not support middle-click, you must use left-click.

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-06-29 Thread krtulmay
Consistency with other tabs opening in the background is fine, but I must agree with Evan on suggesting that the New Tab page should clearly be an exception. Since you can always open an NTP and there are so many ways to do it, you would never want to queue any NTPs in the background, and the onl

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-06-27 Thread Peter Kasting
I argued from the point of consistency and mentioned my personal preference only as an afternote to point out that the consistent behavior would not be universally despised. PK On Jun 27, 2009 4:08 PM, "krtulmay" wrote: This is fine except for the other 50% of users who do want the browser to

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-06-27 Thread krtulmay
This is fine except for the other 50% of users who do want the browser to change tabs for them. And before you reply with "there are more than 50% of users who want new tabs queued in the background" or say that it's your preference, I would like to see explicitly a statement from Google's testin

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-06-26 Thread Peter Kasting
Given that there are a large number of ways to open the home page in a new foreground tab (e.g. ctrl-t + click, shift-middle click, etc.), there are a very large number of other places in the UI where middle-click opens a new background tab (including other toolbar buttons), there are no places I c

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-06-26 Thread Peter Kasting
I don't understand; what's the alternative behavior you're proposing? (Yes, this behavior is intentional; all the toolbar buttons handle clicks/modifiers now, so e.g. middle-clicking the back button opens the previous page in a new background tab. This behavior was a popular niche request and mat

[chromium-dev] Re: middle click on home

2009-06-26 Thread Evan Martin
On Fri, Jun 26, 2009 at 5:06 PM, Peter Kasting wrote: > I don't understand; what's the alternative behavior you're proposing? Sorry, I failed to make that explicit: Open in foreground. (See original mail about false benefits of consistency.) > > (Yes, this behavior is intentional; all the tool