Afghan asylum-seekers en route to Australia are held by police in Kupang, East 
Timor. Picture: AAP


Malcolm Turnbull on attack over asylum-seeker deal 
  a.. Paul Maley 
  b.. From: The Australian 
  c.. November 17, 2009 12:00AM 

MALCOLM Turnbull has accused Kevin Rudd of misleading parliament following an 
admission the Prime Minister's office knew of a preferential deal for the 78 
asylum-seekers aboard the Australian Customs vessel Oceanic Viking. 

As Border Protection officers yesterday intercepted a boatload of 10 
asylum-seekers - the third in 48 hours - Indonesian authorities denied 
soliciting bribes from a group of Afghans whose vessel was fired on, injuring 
two.

And with the asylum-seeker issue straining relations with Jakarta, the Prime 
Minister's office was forced to deny that a decision by Indonesian President 
Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono to postpone his visit to Australia amounted to a 
diplomatic snub.

Yesterday, the Opposition Leader used the first day of the final parliamentary 
sitting period this year to escalate his attack on the Rudd government, 
accusing the Prime Minister of misleading the parliament.

Mr Turnbull's charge followed a torrid parliamentary session in which Mr Rudd 
denied any knowledge of the deal offered to those on board the Oceanic Viking 
to fast-track their resettlement in exchange for them leaving the boat.

When asked if he either knew of, or had approved the deal, which would see 
successful refugees resettled within four to 12 weeks, Mr Rudd said the answer 
was "no and no".

He later said the letter to the asylum-seekers had been formulated by the 
border protection committee of cabinet, on which his staff was represented.

"This government, I as Prime Minister, fully endorse the handling of this 
matter, including this document from the immigration counsellor in Jakarta," Mr 
Rudd said.

But he denied the accelerated processing represented a special deal, citing a 
letter from Immigration head Andrew Metcalfe saying the resettlement timeframes 
were "consistent with international practice".

"The special deal being sought by those on the vessel was for the vessel to 
come to Australia," Mr Rudd said. "We have not responded to that pressure."

Mr Rudd also revealed that a planned visit by Dr Yudhoyono would be more likely 
in February, rather than this month, as originally reported.

Deputy Opposition Leader Julie Bishop last night demanded the Prime Minister 
explain why the visit had been cancelled at the "last minute", saying the 
Liberal Party had been led to believe Dr Yudhoyono would arrive this Sunday. 
"We need to know whether the cancellation has anything to do with the way the 
Prime Minister in particular has handled this Oceanic Viking issue with 
Indonesia," Ms Bishop said on the ABC's Lateline program.

She demanded to know why Mr Rudd had not held meetings with Dr Yudhoyono at the 
APEC conference at the weekend.

"The Prime Minister has used what I would term megaphone diplomacy in dealing 
with Indonesia," Ms Bishop said.

A spokesman for Mr Rudd said the postponement was without any diplomatic 
significance.

Mr Turnbull leapt on the admission that Mr Rudd's staff knew of the deal, 
saying the Prime Minister had not been straight with the Australian public.

In an accusation that drew comparisons with Mr Turnbull's prosecution of the 
Godwin Grech affair, the Opposition Leader accused the Prime Minister of 
misleading parliament.

"There is no question that he has misled the House," Mr Turnbull said.

"There is no question about that. The fact is, it is a preferential deal."

Mr Turnbull nevertheless indicated the deal should be honoured.

"I guess there's been an offer and acceptance," he said. "There's a question 
then of the integrity of the Australian government at stake."

The Opposition Leader's charge earned a swift rebuke from the Prime Minister's 
office.

"It's sad to see Mr Turnbull has learnt nothing from the fake email scandal," 
said a spokesman for Mr Rudd.

"He's happy to produce big claims first and fail to produce evidence later."

Mr Turnbull said there was a "low level" possibility Mr Rudd's staff had not 
told the Prime Minister about the deal with asylum-seekers before it was struck.

The political theatrics came as Border Protection authorities spent a busy 48 
hours intercepting three boats off Australia's northwest coast.

Yesterday, a boat carrying 10 asylum-seekers and one crew was intercepted seven 
nautical miles northeast of Ashmore Islands.

On Saturday, a boat with 47 passengers and three crew was stopped and on Sunday 
Border Protection intercepted a boat with 29 passengers and three crew. So far 
this year, 43 boats carrying a little more than 2000 asylum-seekers have 
arrived on Australian shores.

Yesterday, Indonesian police denied the shooting of two Afghan asylum-seekers 
last week followed an attempt by police to extort money from the boatpeople, 
who were bound for Australia.

Additional reporting: AAP

<<406854-afghan-asylum.jpg>>

Kirim email ke