[cobirds] Re: ID help

2023-03-04 Thread Dave Cameron
Sounds like a "Gray-headed" form of Dark-eyed Junco. On Monday, February 27, 2023 at 5:14:40 PM UTC-7 Gary Brower wrote: > Friends, > > I was birding this afternoon on the Big Dry Creek Trail (in Centennial, CO > —Arapahoe County). And I’m stumped. > > Into a tree flew two birds. One *clearly*

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID of Clark’s vs Western at Sterns Lake (Boulder County)

2021-04-11 Thread Mark Minner-lee
Thanks to all for the helpful descriptions and information. Regards, Mark Minner-Lee Erie, CO Sent from my iPhone > On Apr 11, 2021, at 3:14 PM, Adam Vesely wrote: > > Mlodinow and Leukering (2018) wrote a fantastic and informative piece in > Colorado Birds about identification of Western a

[cobirds] Re: ID of Clark’s vs Western at Sterns Lake (Boulder County)

2021-04-11 Thread Adam Vesely
Mlodinow and Leukering (2018) wrote a fantastic and informative piece in Colorado Birds about identification of Western and Clark's Grebes along with thorough discussion of hybrids. Not sure if this link will work, but try this: https://cobirds.org/Publications/ColoradoBirds/InTheScope/84.pdf

[cobirds] Re: ID of Clark’s vs Western at Sterns Lake (Boulder County)

2021-04-11 Thread John Malenich
I think the photos of the WEGR and CLGR at Stern's Lake posted in Jason Cole's checklist linked below seem to illustrate what Caleb is describing here. https://ebird.org/checklist/S85225919 John Malenich Boulder, CO On Sunday, April 11, 2021 at 11:33:19 AM UTC-6 caleb...@gmail.com wrote: >

[cobirds] Re: ID of Clark’s vs Western at Sterns Lake (Boulder County)

2021-04-11 Thread Caleb A
Hi Mark! For the sake of efficiency, I'll be using WEGR to be Western Grebe and CLGR to be Clark's Grebe. You would be correct that there is variation and therefore ambiguity when it comes to the black and white pattern on the face. From my limited experience, WEGR tends to be the species that

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID?

2020-09-26 Thread Steven Rash
Looking at it more carefully I agree with Joe, and David’s agreement. As with most things, the best way to get an answer on the internet is not to ask a question, but to post the wrong answer. Murphy’s law. Steve Rash Denver Co. > On Sep 26, 2020, at 11:52 AM, Joe Roller wrote: > >  > Ap

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID?

2020-09-26 Thread Joe Roller
Appears to be a Hermit Thrush, based on dark markings on chest and lack of buff on face. Joe Roller, Denver On Sat, Sep 26, 2020 at 11:44 AM Steven Rash wrote: > Appears to be a Swainson's Thrush, which belongs to the same family as > Robins here in America do. The other one of these that you wi

[cobirds] Re: ID?

2020-09-26 Thread Steven Rash
Appears to be a Swainson's Thrush, which belongs to the same family as Robins here in America do. The other one of these that you will run into more commonly is the Hermit Thrush which can be distinguished from Swainson's by its rust-colored tail. Hope that is helpful! Happy birding, Steve

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Which Eagle?

2020-07-16 Thread raptoresse
Yep, I concur with Michael for all of the reasons mentioned. No yellow in cere; it's in the gape. Fresh, dark plumage, not yet faded in the Colorado sun. ~Anne Price Littleton, Jefferson County On Wednesday, July 15, 2020 at 9:59:36 AM UTC-6, Michael T wrote: > > Hatch year recently fledged Bal

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Which Eagle?

2020-07-15 Thread 'The "Nunn Guy"' via Colorado Birds
Hi all Thanks for playing all ... indeed Bald Eagle (identified as such on photos, too). I certainly picked up some new tips hope others did as well. Thanks Gary Lefko, Nunn http://www.friendsofthepawneegrassland.org https://www.inaturalist.org/projects/birds-and-more-of-the-pawnee-national-gra

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Which Eagle?

2020-07-15 Thread Michael T
More importantly, the pictures that you posted say "Bald eagle". :-) On Monday, July 13, 2020 at 1:45:27 PM UTC-6 The "Nunn Guy" wrote: > Hi all > > Photoed this handsome and cooperative eagle in Weld County over the > weekend. Thought it would offer a lively discussion for "which eagle and >

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Which Eagle?

2020-07-15 Thread Joe Roller
Gary, All you asked for was the *species* of eagle, so I'd say the large bill is "all Bald Eagle" and never mind the plumage. Joe Roller, Denver On Wed, Jul 15, 2020 at 9:59 AM Michael T wrote: > Hatch year recently fledged Bald Eagle. Fairly uniform dark coloration. A > second year bird would

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Which Eagle?

2020-07-15 Thread Michael T
Hatch year recently fledged Bald Eagle. Fairly uniform dark coloration. A second year bird would have worn more variation on the chest.Eye color is a consistent dark color. Feathers on the head a uniform in color. Michael Tincher Loveland,CO On Monday, July 13, 2020 at 1:45:27 PM UTC-6, The "

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Which Eagle?

2020-07-14 Thread Rick Reeser
Sibley's Guide has a good drawing of a 2nd year bald eagle, showing the light dark band on the end of the tail and the white on the front. That is clearly showing on photos 23 & 24. Rick Reeser, Greeley On Monday, July 13, 2020 at 1:45:27 PM UTC-6, The "Nunn Guy" wrote: > > Hi all > > Photoed th

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Which Eagle?

2020-07-13 Thread Beverly Head
I am guessing that it's a young bald eagle. Partly because of the white part in the tail, but still mostly dark in the rest of its body, with the exception of some white spots in the chest. On Monday, July 13, 2020 at 1:45:27 PM UTC-6, The "Nunn Guy" wrote: > > Hi all > > Photoed this handsome a

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Which Eagle?

2020-07-13 Thread John Ealy
Aack. Neglected to sign off. John Ealy Roxborough Park, Douglas County, CO On Monday, July 13, 2020 at 3:24:17 PM UTC-6, John Ealy wrote: > > I'm guessing 2- to 3-year-old bald eagle based on the ventral view of > white tail with narrow dark outer edge and irregular dark band on tail tip. >

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Which Eagle?

2020-07-13 Thread John Ealy
I'm guessing 2- to 3-year-old bald eagle based on the ventral view of white tail with narrow dark outer edge and irregular dark band on tail tip. Bird also has white and dark streaks on the neck area. Cere appears to be partially yellow. Large bill. Dark eye. Sure has a full crop. n Monday

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Greeley Hummer

2020-06-23 Thread 'The "Nunn Guy"' via Colorado Birds
Hi all Here is a more definitive explanation for Black-chinned Hummingbird: "Here in Phoenix, we get Anna's, Costa's, and Black-chinned as our expected and common hummingbirds, so separation of the three is something we deal with every day. I can tell you with certainty it's not the two former

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Greeley Hummer

2020-06-23 Thread 'The "Nunn Guy"' via Colorado Birds
Hi all Just received comment to add to discussion: - "Actually, Costa’s might be the best fit shape-wise and tail/wing length fits too. I’m unable to see 'strongly-curved wingtips.'" Thanks, Gary Lefko, Nunn http://www.friendsofthepawneegrassland.org/ On Tuesday, June 23, 2020 at 8:11:4

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Greeley Hummer

2020-06-23 Thread 'The "Nunn Guy"' via Colorado Birds
Hi all Other responses so far most leaning toward Black-chinned: - "Not the greatest photo, but messing with filters and light adjustments, I think it’s an Archilochus type, and given the apparently pointy rater than clubby shape of the primaries, I’d call it a Ruby-throated rather

[cobirds] Re: ID Challenge: Greeley Hummer

2020-06-22 Thread Dave Cameron
Wings about as long as the tail, bill very straight, short stubby bird, getting no help from the gorget due to the lighting angle, though it lacks any frills or extensions Makes me want to guess Anna's, though that would be highly unexpected. Looks a little chunky for Black-chinned, though

[cobirds] Re: ID Assistance: Willow Springs

2020-05-31 Thread Natalie
Red-tailed Hawk On Sunday, May 31, 2020 at 2:11:35 PM UTC-6, NicMar wrote: > > Hi there. Can anyone assist in ID’ing this Hawk? Northern Goshawk? > Ferruginous? > > Any insight is much appreciated! > > Nicolle Martin > Littleton, CO > > > -- You received this message because you are subscrib

[cobirds] Re: id help please ... Prospect Ponds, Larimer

2020-05-08 Thread Steven Rash
The one possibility that comes to mind is Baird's Sparrow. You may have spotted one on its way over to Soapstone where they are known to breed. If that is indeed it, you saved yourself a hellish walk in unsheltered conditions come summertime. One thing I like to keep in mind when mulling birds

[cobirds] Re: ID help on a goose sp., Larimer

2019-11-16 Thread Dave Cameron
I'm no geneticist, but Sibley says that all manner of color gradients exist in Blue Snow Goose. And this bird clearly has the dainty bill of a Ross.' Suggesting Snow x Ross' hybrid. Dave Cameron Denver On Saturday, November 16, 2019 at 11:15:42 AM UTC-7, Joe Kipper wrote: > > Hey Birders, >

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID help requested - Spatula hybrid - Cottonwood Hollow (Larimer)

2019-03-25 Thread Nicholas Komar
Check out photos online for Australasian Shoveler. Adult male has a white facial crescent. Nick Komar Fort Collins CO > On Mar 25, 2019, at 3:50 PM, Sean Walters > wrote: > > Well, taking that idea a step further, I have seen a few male Northern > Shovelers with limited "white-face-crescent

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID help requested - Spatula hybrid - Cottonwood Hollow (Larimer)

2019-03-25 Thread Sean Walters
Well, taking that idea a step further, I have seen a few male Northern Shovelers with limited "white-face-crescents" (they were barely present in the birds I can recall). Birds of North America states (for Alternate I, male NOSH) Head and neck black with iridescent green medially. Some birds show

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID help requested - Spatula hybrid - Cottonwood Hollow (Larimer)

2019-03-25 Thread David Tønnessen
Intriguing, nice investigation Sean. A search on eBird's Macaulay Library also shows nearly all male Northern Shoveler x Cinnamon Teal hybrids with a white crescent and rufous breast area (a more understandable trait) like this bird. https://ebird.org/media/catalog?taxonCode=x00630&q=Cinnamon%2

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID help requested - Spatula hybrid - Cottonwood Hollow (Larimer)

2019-03-25 Thread Sean Walters
A little "Googling" came up with a few interesting leads. https://www.flickr.com/groups/444365@N25/discuss/72157629157445778/ http://www.1birds.com/hybrid-teals.htm http://birdhybrids.blogspot.com/2014/04/cinnamon-teal-x-northern-shoveler.html A nicely done paper that includes photos of a kno

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID help requested - Spatula hybrid - Cottonwood Hollow (Larimer)

2019-03-25 Thread David Tønnessen
I'm curious, are there any good sources or studies saying that CITE x NOSH combo can show a white crescent identical to that of BWTE and what causes that gene expression? If not, I'm not sure what leads away from a BWTE x NOSH ID. Just my thoughts. David Tonnessen Colorado Springs -- You re

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID help requested - Spatula hybrid - Cottonwood Hollow (Larimer)

2019-03-25 Thread Dave Silverman
Yep--I agree. B-w TealxShoveler hybrid. Dave Silverman Rye CO From: cobirds@googlegroups.com on behalf of Nicholas Komar Sent: Monday, March 25, 2019 9:22 AM To: fiddlen...@aol.com Cc: joe.kippe...@gmail.com; Colorado Birds Subject: Re: [cobirds] Re: ID help

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID help requested - Spatula hybrid - Cottonwood Hollow (Larimer)

2019-03-25 Thread Nicholas Komar
Blue-winged Teal can have bright red eyes (see photos on Birds-eye App). Looks good for BWTE x northern shoveler. Nick Komar Fort Collins CO > On Mar 25, 2019, at 2:59 AM, 'Deborah Carstensen' via Colorado Birds > wrote: > > I’ve never seen a cinnamon teal with a crescent on its face. I woul

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID help requested - Spatula hybrid - Cottonwood Hollow (Larimer)

2019-03-25 Thread 'Deborah Carstensen' via Colorado Birds
I’ve never seen a cinnamon teal with a crescent on its face. I would go towards blue winged teal. Sent from my iPhone > On Mar 24, 2019, at 9:09 PM, joe.kippe...@gmail.com wrote: > > I agree with Michael... > The red eye also leads me to think that Cinnamon Teal is in the mix > somewhere. Sho

[cobirds] Re: ID help requested - Spatula hybrid - Cottonwood Hollow (Larimer)

2019-03-24 Thread joe . kipper28
I agree with Michael... The red eye also leads me to think that Cinnamon Teal is in the mix somewhere. Shovelers have yellow eyes and Blue Winged Teal have black eyes, so I don't see where else the red eye could come from. Also, Blue-winged Teal x Shoveler hybrids normally don't have rusty flank

[cobirds] Re: ID help - Larimer Co Rd 5

2015-07-29 Thread David Wade
Howdy Folks, First, thanks to all those people that replied either here or to me personally. I appreciate your feedback. I've figured out exactly where I went off track on my path of identification. I use the book form of Sibley's 1st edition in the field. There I saw that Spragues Pipet has

RE: [Bulk] [cobirds] Re: ID help - Larimer Co Rd 5

2015-07-29 Thread Jeff J Jones
ject: [Bulk] [cobirds] Re: ID help - Larimer Co Rd 5 Looks like I did it, I made myself a fool. Nick Komar straightened me out. Turns out they are Horned Larks. Mea Culpa David Wade Ft Collins On Wednesday, July 29, 2015 at 12:43:33 AM UTC-6, David Wade wrote: -- You received this mess

Re: [cobirds] Re: ID help - Larimer Co Rd 5

2015-07-29 Thread 'Deborah Carstensen' via Colorado Birds
Oh, come on, you're not a fool! Every time people reach out for help on IDs they're taking a risk of looking silly, but what better use of this format than to get help with birds? The more people ask for help with IDs, the more others, like myself, will be willing to do the same. Then some o

[cobirds] Re: ID help - Larimer Co Rd 5

2015-07-29 Thread David Wade
Looks like I did it, I made myself a fool. Nick Komar straightened me out. Turns out they are Horned Larks. Mea Culpa David Wade Ft Collins On Wednesday, July 29, 2015 at 12:43:33 AM UTC-6, David Wade wrote: > > > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups

[cobirds] Re: id help please...bird song from Sierra Nevada

2014-06-12 Thread 'ronbco' via Colorado Birds
Thanks to those who responded! The verdict is a Hermit Thrush! Beautiful song! I think I had not considered it before because I observed it singing from tall tree tops. Also I had not realized how much smaller and more slender than other thrushes. Ron Bolton Berthoud On Wednesday, June 11, 201

[cobirds] Re: id help please

2014-03-21 Thread ronbco
apologies from forgetting protocol on postings wrt name and area Ron Bolton, Berthoud On Friday, March 21, 2014 1:14:18 PM UTC-6, ronbco wrote: > > While on a chair lift at Copper Mtn, saw a small bird feeding on the top > of a douglas fir tree at 11k elev. > Not sure if it was going for the fir

[cobirds] Re: ID Help (Glenmere Park)/Weld

2013-08-13 Thread Laurence
Hi. Looks like an Eastern Kingbird. Laurence. On Tuesday, August 13, 2013 10:58:34 AM UTC-6, The "Nunn Guy" wrote: > > At work, don't have any book(s) handy, your help appreciated. Taken at > Glenmere Park in Greeley. > > coloradobirder.ning.com/photo/id-2 > coloradobirder.ning.com/photo/id-h

[cobirds] Re: id help please

2012-08-11 Thread kickback
Ron, sounds like a rock wren to me. Send me your email address and I'll send you good pictures of both birds. Bill bill_ ko...@msn.com On Saturday, August 11, 2012 8:10:06 PM UTC-6, ronbco wrote: > Pueblo Nature Center, along the Arkansas river, along the trail east of > the Nature cente

[cobirds] Re: ID (by sound) help please

2012-06-22 Thread Joey Kellner
To me the description matches perfectly that of a Thirteen-lined Ground Squirrel. Habitat matches this species as well. :-) Joey Kellner Littleton, CO On Friday, June 22, 2012 9:14:28 AM UTC-6, ronbco wrote: > In a grassy field in Longmont heard an unfamiliar call. > fairly high pitched, 6

[cobirds] Re: ID help

2010-10-04 Thread Julia Bond
> Wow, I have received some very wonderful answers that illustrates just how > hard identification of juvie or different variations of hawks can be. I > have read several different replies saying it was different types of RT's or > Juvie RT, Juvie Swainson's, possible Roughy, etc. All of the opini

[cobirds] Re: id help

2010-03-18 Thread john polo
Greetings, Thanks to the people who helped me. It's practically unanimous that the hawk was a Northern Goshawk. A couple of folks have suggested Townsend's Solitaire for the songster. I've listened to the samples online and they don't seem to last as long as the songs I heard yesterday. However,