Re: questions about hadoop map reduce and compute intensive related applications

2011-05-02 Thread gmackey
Integrating MPI with map-reduce is currently difficult and/or very ugly, however. Not impossible and there are hackish ways to do the job, but they are hacks. There is an project out of Sandia National Lab that puts MR and MPI together in a library if you're interested --

Re: questions about hadoop map reduce and compute intensive related applications

2011-04-30 Thread Ted Dunning
On Sat, Apr 30, 2011 at 12:18 AM, elton sky eltonsky9...@gmail.com wrote: I got 2 questions: 1. I am wondering how hadoop MR performs when it runs compute intensive applications, e.g. Monte carlo method compute PI. There's a example in 0.21, QuasiMonteCarlo, but that example doesn't use

Re: questions about hadoop map reduce and compute intensive related applications

2011-04-30 Thread elton sky
Ted, MPI supports node-to-node communications in ways that map-reduce does not, however, which requires that you iterate map-reduce steps for many algorithms. With Hadoop's current implementation, this is horrendously slow (minimum 20-30 seconds per iteration). Sometimes you can avoid this