Re: [CLI] XML Support (was Re: [CLI] Status)

2004-12-30 Thread David Morris
Rob, Thanks for the feedback. I agree that it should be a design goal to minimize reliance on outside packages. The XMLBuilder that I am working on uses a SAX parser and doesn't require any outside package as long as you are using a 1.4+ JDK. Those using an earlier JDK will need to have a parser l

[CLI] XML Support (was Re: [CLI] Status)

2004-12-30 Thread Rob Oxspring
Modelling a cli in xml has been talked about in the past and there are a couple of things you might want to take into consideration if you are going to implement such a feature. Firstly, there is the question of whether to parse the xml at runtime or build time - runtime introduces another dep

Re: [CLI] Status

2004-12-30 Thread Rob Oxspring
Thanks for the testcase - I'll give it a shot in a while. It sounds like the missing properties are accidental and should be exposed via the builders, I'll try and address the group id later but let me know about any others (or send a patch!). I'll split my XML related reply into a separate thre

Re: [CLI] Status

2004-12-27 Thread David Morris
Rob, Thanks for applying all of the patches and getting CLI into shape. I will supply a test case for 32533. I have been working on an XMLBuilder that uses an XML document to describe Options, Arguements, and Groups. Hopefully it will be useful to CLI. While working on this I found that not all pr

Re: [CLI] Status

2004-12-23 Thread David Morris
Thanks for responding. I am glad that you will find some time to look at the patches. I have looked at the outstanding bugs and quite a few are fixed by using CLI2 or applying the outstanding patches. I am guessing it would be helpful to add a test to show that this is the case for the existing bug

Re: [CLI] Status

2004-12-23 Thread Rob Oxspring
Hi, Sorry for the lack of response to your patch, I've been really busy with the day job lately and CLI2 has effectively stalled in the meantime. Hopefully I'll find some time between xmas and new year to get things in motion again. The main thing that needs doing is to go through bugzilla revi

[CLI] Status

2004-12-22 Thread David Morris
I used the COMMONS CLI package for a couple of recent projects and I ran into some serious problems and submitted some patches. Next, I tried version 2, which appears to be a ground up rewrite. It worked a lot better after a couple of minor tweaks and a patch. I don't see much activity lately in CV