Re: [computer-go] CGOS Deflation or Self-Play delusion?

2008-02-03 Thread RĂ©mi Coulom
I believe the main problem is that the Elo-rating model is wrong for bots. The phenomenon with Mogo is probably the same as Crazy Stone: if there are enough strong MC bots playing to shield the top MC programs from playing against GNU, then they'll get a high rating because they are efficient

[computer-go] CGOS Deflation or Self-Play delusion?

2008-02-02 Thread Gian-Carlo Pascutto
I'm not sure what to think about the following: Leela 0.3.0 vs Leela 0.3.7, 455 game match 177 vs 278 = +78 ELO points for Leela 0.3.7 CGOS rating Leela_0.3.0_1CPU 2335 Leela_0.3.7_2CPU 2333 Hmm..but also Zen-0.9 2386 Zen-1.0 2385 or more: Uct-200801122348 Uct-200801132334

Re: [computer-go] CGOS Deflation or Self-Play delusion?

2008-02-02 Thread Yamato
Gian-Carlo Pascutto wrote: I'm not sure what to think about the following: Leela 0.3.0 vs Leela 0.3.7, 455 game match 177 vs 278 = +78 ELO points for Leela 0.3.7 CGOS rating Leela_0.3.0_1CPU 2335 Leela_0.3.7_2CPU 2333 Hmm..but also Zen-0.9 2386 Zen-1.0 2385 I think it