[coreboot] Re: FSP 2.4: runtime blobs!

2022-09-30 Thread ron minnich
Laurie, thanks for the invite. If ever a single statement crystallized the problem, this is it: "Intel® FSP is an ingredient to a full system firmware solution and incorporates multiple bootloaders including coreboot." That's the problem: " incorporates multiple bootloaders including coreboot".

[coreboot] Re: FSP 2.4: runtime blobs!

2022-09-30 Thread Arthur Heymans
Hi Laurie I created a github issue about this https://github.com/UniversalScalableFirmware/documentation/issues/37 almost 11 months ago with no reply. I also don't see any discussions about FSP-I in particular in that community but I posted my github issue again on that mailing list. Arthur On

[coreboot] Re: FSP 2.4: runtime blobs!

2022-09-30 Thread Jarlstrom, Laurie
Hi, I would like to invite you to the Universal Scalable Firmware (USF) Community where Intel® FSP is an ingredient to a full system firmware solution and incorporates multiple bootloaders including coreboot. There have been discussions on the updates to Intel® FSP within this community

[coreboot] Re: FSP 2.4: runtime blobs!

2022-09-30 Thread ron minnich
note that I am having this exact same problem in the RISC-V community: https://github.com/riscv-non-isa/riscv-sbi-doc/issues/102 People just like their SMM. It's hard to kill. I fear that you're not going to get much luck with Intel, which is why I try to work with non-Intel CPUs as much as I

[coreboot] Re: FSP 2.4: runtime blobs!

2022-09-30 Thread Nico Huber
Hi Arthur, coreboot fellows, On 30.09.22 13:53, Arthur Heymans wrote: > What are your thoughts? printing, bonfire... > Do we take a stance against FSP-I integration in coreboot? I think we already do. From coreboot.org: "coreboot is an extended firmware platform that delivers a lightning