Re: [courier-users] error "534 Message header size, or recipient list..." triggered by message body??

2004-05-09 Thread Jeff Potter
Maybe you could fix it? Heh. That's a good suggestion... ;-) Some of the threads on this list are insane. It would take far less time and effort to simply edit the 2-3 lines of code and recompile than to argue technical minutia day after day and get nothing done. Given that you know the charac

Re: [courier-users] error "534 Message header size, or recipient list..." triggered by message body??

2004-05-08 Thread Michael Carmack
Jeff Potter wrote: Given that the RFCs are vague, and that EVERY server we've tested (except Courier) supports insanely long line lengths (we tested with 1,000,000 byte-long lines), it looks incredibly bad for us and Courier that it doesn't work on our system. There's a lot of RFC-enforcing that

Re: [courier-users] error "534 Message header size, or recipient list..." triggered by message body??

2004-05-08 Thread Jeff Potter
Given that the RFCs are vague, and that EVERY server we've tested (except Courier) supports insanely long line lengths (we tested with 1,000,000 byte-long lines), it looks incredibly bad for us and Courier that it doesn't work on our system. There's a lot of RFC-enforcing that I'm willing to argue

RE: [courier-users] error "534 Message header size, or recipient list..." triggered by message body??

2004-05-08 Thread Sebastian Lechte
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 dear jeff, > Given that the RFCs are vague, and that EVERY server we've tested > (except Courier) supports insanely long line lengths (we tested with > 1,000,000 byte-long lines), it looks incredibly bad for us > and Courier > that it doesn't work on

Re: [courier-users] error "534 Message header size, or recipient list..." triggered by message body??

2004-05-08 Thread Jeff Potter
Anyway, how do they get 5000 characters on a line? They must be trying hard, as I rarely send emails with anything near that amount of characters, and any decent email client linewraps at 80-100 characters, even hotmail! Exactly what client are they using, and what are they trying to do? I hav

Re: [courier-users] error "534 Message header size, or recipient list..." triggered by message body??

2004-05-08 Thread Jeff Potter
It is significant that the rfc says, "the body is simply a sequence of characters", rather than a sequence of lines. This could be interpreted to mean that the body has no line length. Exactly. I'd never write software that spit out huge lines myself, but I'm having a really hard time explai

Re: [courier-users] error "534 Message header size, or recipient list..." triggered by message body??

2004-05-08 Thread Martijn Lievaart
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Phillip Hutchings <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I would have thought that the following section 2.1.1 would have clarified this. No, it doesn't. Well, 2.1 says: Messages are divided into lines of characters. A line is a series of characters that is delimited w

Re: [courier-users] error "534 Message header size, or recipient list..." triggered by message body??

2004-05-08 Thread davidn-courier
Phillip Hutchings <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > I would have thought that the following section 2.1.1 would have > clarified this. No, it doesn't. --- This SF.Net email is sponsored by Sleepycat Software Learn developer strategies Cisco, Motor

Re: [courier-users] error "534 Message header size, or recipient list..." triggered by message body??

2004-05-07 Thread Phillip Hutchings
On 8/05/2004, at 3:15 PM, David Newall wrote: On Sat, 2004-05-08 at 09:13, Sam Varshavchik wrote: Jeff Potter writes: able to accept message bodies with any line length. There's nothing in the RFCs that indicate that a line length in the body itself must be bounded to a certain size; Unfortunate

Re: [courier-users] error "534 Message header size, or recipient list..." triggered by message body??

2004-05-07 Thread David Newall
On Sat, 2004-05-08 at 09:13, Sam Varshavchik wrote: > Jeff Potter writes: > > able to accept message bodies with any line length. There's nothing in > > the RFCs that indicate that a line length in the body itself must be > > bounded to a certain size; > > Unfortunately, you're wrong. > [...] >

[courier-users] error "534 Message header size, or recipient list..." triggered by message body??

2004-05-07 Thread Jeff Potter
Hi Sam, We've had a number of people complain about Courier refusing to accept messages with the "534 Message header size, or recipient list, exceeds policy limit" error. Problem is, their messages don't exceed the limit in the headers. (I can send you tcpdumps of the smtp transaction off-list