[Crm-sig] CRMInf ISSUE: J2 concluded that

2018-09-18 Thread Martin Doerr
Dear All, I wonder if the scope note of J2 concluded that should be: Scope note:    " This property associates an instance of I2 Belief with the instance of I1 Argumentation that concluded it." Or should be: Scope note:    " This property associates an instance of I2 Belief with the

Re: [Crm-sig] Parent of F4 Manifestation Singleton

2018-09-18 Thread Martin Doerr
Dear Oeyvind, Well, I expressed just a more theoretical thought. There is a question of identity conditions: Is the product providing the identity to the activity, or the activity to the product? If the products are more loosely coupled such as multiple recordings, reviews etc., obviously the

Re: [Crm-sig] Question about CRMArcheo and its completion

2018-09-18 Thread Achille Felicetti
Dear Franco, Sure :-)) Done! A. > Il giorno 18 set 2018, alle ore 15:04, Franco Niccolucci > ha scritto: > > Achille, > > maybe you have a more recent draft version - the one being reviewed by Steve > for some time now - which might be more useful to Christian-Emil than the > outdated one

Re: [Crm-sig] Question about CRMArcheo and its completion

2018-09-18 Thread Franco Niccolucci
Achille, maybe you have a more recent draft version - the one being reviewed by Steve for some time now - which might be more useful to Christian-Emil than the outdated one publicly available. If so, you could send it directly to him (and not to the list). Franco Prof. Franco Niccolucci Dire

Re: [Crm-sig] Question about CRMArcheo and its completion

2018-09-18 Thread Achille Felicetti
Dear Christian-Emil, As you might have guessed, CMRarchaeo’s documentation is still a work in progress and many efforts are currently taking place to improve and finalise it. In particular, version 1.4.5 has already been extended with new real cases and examples, and many scope notes have been

Re: [Crm-sig] Parent of F4 Manifestation Singleton

2018-09-18 Thread Øyvind Eide
Well, performances are usually not part of library or museum collections. The theatre museums I have worked with collect artefacts, texts, stage models etc. etc. but not performances. They do collect traces of performances though: reviews, programmes, posters, stage drawings, costumes, video rec

Re: [Crm-sig] NEW ISSUE: symbolic content

2018-09-18 Thread Richard Light
Right, so we are defining a new CRM property, with domain E90 Symbolic Object and range E62 String. Agreed? I suggest that we call it "Pxxx has string value" to make its purpose clearer. E62 String is defined more widely than the strings we are currently considering: it includes "bitmaps, vec

[Crm-sig] Question about CRMArcheo and its completion

2018-09-18 Thread Christian-Emil Smith Ore
Dear all, I participate in an archeological infrastructure project (financed by the Norwegian Research Council) for data from archaeological excavations in Norway. The objectives is to link datasets form excavations, museum collections and archives. My task is to plan the use of CIDOC-CRM and

Re: [Crm-sig] Parent of F4 Manifestation Singleton

2018-09-18 Thread Martin Doerr
Dear George, How nice! I believe the concept of "Expression" as something permanent, i.e., the FRBR concept of it, actually confuses the problem. "Expression" is to my understanding a process, an activity, and only in a second meaning the product. I do not see any difference to lots of best s

Re: [Crm-sig] Parent of F4 Manifestation Singleton

2018-09-18 Thread Athanasios Velios
LRM-E4 Manifestation is talking about sets of "carriers" which I think is fine. LRM-E5 Item is defined as: "An object or objects carrying signs intended to convey intellectual or artistic content." which may be problematic, especially when the scope note refers to a "portion of the disk" for dig

Re: [Crm-sig] NEW ISSUE: symbolic content

2018-09-18 Thread Nicola Carboni
Dear Martin, I can confirm that having symbolic content as subclass of rdf:value would incredibly help!! Best, Nicola > On 17 Sep 2018, at 21:38, Robert Sanderson wrote: > > > Examples I have a lot of! > > > How about … > > * The materials description (E33) of the painting